Dr. Khan was fed up with MGA by 1906..MGA’s claims kept advancing, he was making bolder and bolder claims…in the below, I present a summary of Dr. Khan’s letter to Noorudin. Dr. Khan talks about how MGA was wasting money and spending his members donations on jewelry for his wife and other ways which were a big problem.
I have written many entries on this subject. See the below….
MIRZA CHARGE SHEETED BY DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI.
LETTER TO MOLVI NOORUDDIN FROM DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI.
ZIKRUL HAKIM PAGE 368-378
Dr. Abdul Hakim Khan Patialvi was a keen follower of MGAQ, remained in his jamaat for 20 years. Then he found wrongdoings of Mirza and violation of Quraanic teachings and commandments of Allah Swt by MGAQ and his Jamaat. He made correspondence with MGAQ and Molvi Nooruddin for reform and correction but both MGAQ and Nooruddin rejected his criticism. This correspondence is very lengthy contains heavy Arabic and Persian idioms and phrases, studded with Quraanic verses and ahadis. So it is not easy to be translated in english word to word in a short time. However, I have tried to present central idea of the correspondence as under:-
Subhanallah what a logic is this, Quraan teaches us to say salam but u deny and do not say salam to me in your letter. U termed my word of Basis of salvation (madar e nijat) as vague whereas your whole letter is vague.
I have always been the truth seeker. I am the same Abdul Hakim whose translation and commentary of Quraan has been greatly admired by Mirza Qadiyani. Whenever i read my tafseer to mgaq he could not advise a valuable points, he only said admiration. However i got valuable correction addition of points and advise from you whenever I read it over to u. He could not advise on the debate of Hazrat Suleman a.s and said I will explain it to u after consulting a book, WHICH WAS never found by him ever.
I took allegiance of Mirza in the hope of my spiritual and knowledge uplift which could not be achieved. Unfortunately, after my reform request, this very tafseer and my other books have been returned stuffed in gunny bag reached to me in a bad shape.
In the beginning Mirza sb used to say that I am only Maseel e Masih then a masih mehdi, sub ordinate prophet, better than all prophets and then Allah s son then Allah states his praise in the heavens thus committing shirk. Not only this he went to the extent of insulting other prophets and chosen persons.
His claim that earthquake in other parts of world have come due to my rejection, is also a foolish idea, how can Allah punish those with earthquake who have not even heard of MGAQ and his claims. It did not happen in the time of Harat Muhammad s.a.w that He was rejected and victimised by peoples of Makkah but peoples of other areas are killed.So Noorddin sb support of this argument of mirza does not suit to a person of your calibre.
I believe in Allah and his prophets alike as Quraan says کل امن با اللہ وملائکتہ وکتبہ ورسلہ لا نفرق بین احد من الرسلہ
But Mirza denied this verse when he said ” believing in Allah and prophets is of no use unless one does not believe in me. He published that God Says O Ahmed if u were not there I wouldn,t have created skies. He did hundreds of such things against Islam and Quraan. Few of which are described here as under:-
UNENDING BREACHES OF COMMITMENTS.
Donations were asked for, and mostly received for publishing baraheen and other books but books were not published as per commitment nor the money received as charity or Zakat was returned. Such money is being eaten up.
When there was no funds for publishing of baraheen why Reward Ishtihar of thousands of Rs were published. Why peoples were abused with Haramzada without Devine knowledge.
Abusive and obnoxious Language
Molvis who were opposing for the sake of Islam were called as waladul haram, (illegitimate), swine , cursed, satan, blind, etc etc
COMFORT LOVING AND MAN OF STOMACH
What Mirza do is that collect Chanda upto 700 or 800 per month arranged best food for himself and others, amber musk. Kewra, tonics, dry fruits and kernels are made available and used abundantly.
I to 1.5 mound was supplied daily from Lahore during the illness of Molvi Abdul Karim. Bivi sahiba had so much jewellery that Mirza has mortgaged his garden to her for a loan of Rs. 1000 cash and jewellery worth Rs. 4000, Traveled upto Dehli in upper class of train for the sake of Bivi sahiba only. Whereas Hazrat Muhammad s.A.w. Has spent a simple life in a small house, had food after 3 days mostly. Now tell me should I follow Hazrat Muhammad s.a.w or the comfortable life of Mirza Qadiyani.
Hazrat Muhammad s.a.w made the arabs pagan as brother to each others Today with his abusive language and false claims created a divide and schism that can not be repaired.
Should we follow mirza on the issue of Hajj or the Quraan which instruct the rich men to perform Hajj.
ASKING FOR ZAKAT FOR HIS BOOKS.
He asked for zakat money for his books and sold them on highest price.
SHOULD WE FOLLOW THIS SUNNAH OF MIRZA.
FALSE CLAIMS FOR SELF GREATNESS
HE SAID GOD SAYS TO ME THAT U r from me and Iam from u. To me u r like my son.
CONSTRUCTION OF MINARAT.
Construction minarat in Qadiyan is useless and waste of money and against ahadis.
It is absolutely against islam and Quraan and an insult to the prophets and quraam.o hadis.
INSULT OF JESUS CHRIST PBUH.
MIRZA HAS INSULTED HAZRAT ESSA A.S AND TERMED HIS MIRCLE AS JOKE.
MIRZA IMPOSED MONTHLY CHANDA FOR EACH MEMBER in case of non payment his name will be struck down from bayaat.
I am ready to accept any true advise but cant tolerate with above mentioned ideas of mirza which are against Quraan o sunnah.
Humble self Abdul Hakim Khan
Now residing at Trouri District Karnal.