Search

ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

Search results

"Abdul Hakim Khan"

Mirza Masroor Ahmad mentions Dr. Abdul Hakim Khan of Patiala in his Friday Sermon of July 22, 2016

Intro
Some new information has emerged in terms of Dr. Khan of Patiala, we have written about him extensively here: https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/?s=Dr.+Khan+of+Patiala.  We have also added a video.  In this video, Mirza Masroor tells the world that Noorudin supervised this Tafsir by Dr. Khan, nonetheless, they threw the book out since it might make their library filthy.

The video

DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI mentions the death of Maulvi Abdul Karim in his correspondence with MGA

Intro
I continue posting translations and summaries of the correspondence between MGA and Dr. ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI.  Below is another translation to add to the list…

Also read these:

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/07/21/dr-abdul-hakim-khan-patialvi-vs-mga-continued/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/07/16/dr-abdul-hakim-khan-patialvi-speaks-vs-mirza-ghulam-ahmad-1906-1907/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/07/15/dr-abdul-hakim-khan-predicted-mirza-ghulam-ahmads-death-the-evidence/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/06/07/a-word-for-word-translation-of-the-writings-of-dr-abdul-hakeen-khan-of-patiala/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/06/05/dr-khan-wrote-that-ahmadis-were-worhipping-mga-not-allah/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/05/07/new-research-data-books-by-dr-abdul-hakeem-khan-have-been-found-vs-mga/

TO MIRZA GHULAM QADIYANI 
FROM DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI.
LETTER NO 7.
Zikrul Hakim page 40-42

HAZRAT MASIHUZZAMAN,
ASSALAMO ALAIKUM,
Last night before going to bed, I called my God and made my humble prayers and said O my God you say in Quraan that i would forgive every thing except shirk whereas your Masih e Maoud (mirza) says Allah will not forgive disbelieving in me and will forgive everything else. Now should i deny your words or the words of your Masih?

I said to my God O my Sustainer you have always ignored my weaknesses and forgave my mistakes. U also know that what ever good deeds I do are only for your sake and to please U. U always answered my prayers, assisted me sympathised to me. U r not cruel, harsh and ungrateful like Mirza Ghulam Qadyani.

To the core of my heart i am ever ready to accept truth but it is self praising, self worshipping and harsh Mirza who did not reply to me. So what should I do. After this submission i saw a dream that Colonel Fateh Muhammad Khan came to me Abdul Ghani khan is also seen and asking for treatment of his father,s appendicitis. He showed me a prescription containing many anti gastric medicines and told me that these medicines did not work. Then I told Fateh Muhammad Khan that Mirza had removed me from his Jamaat. It has been good for me that i have been removed from Jamaat for the sake of truth. Then in the dream I say who is mirza in front of Allah and say very soon thunderbolt might fall from sky on this jamaat and kill them all.

On the basis of this dream I am writing to you again that Moosa a.s ordered murder of those who committed shirk whereas you support such peoples of your Jamaat. Now I present comparison of your revelations with Quraan.
* In Your ilham you say, may God give me authority over fire. Quraan says Allah has the authority on everything and the rule on the day of judgement.
* Your ilham says about yourself Ya Shamsu wa Ya Qamaru. (Sun and moon) But i say your light has not illuminated even Qadiyan and your family.
* Quraan says All praise to Allah, whereas your ilham says Allah praises you in the heavens.
* You say people in France Italy and Columbia killed by earthquake due to my disobedience. On the contrary, your worst enemies and opponents like Molvi Muhaammad Hussain, Sanaullah Amritsari, Owner of Paisa Akhbar and Peshawari Group have not been killed despite their worst opposition.

For God sake you test yourself and your jamaat on this standrad as to how much u and jamaat worship Allah and how much do u worship a man. I request you to return my first letter as i want to publish this correspondence so that good natured peoples could benefit from this. If u do not return it, i will publish it with the help of my memory because i dont have its copy.

Was the tragic death of Molvi Abdul Karim not a sufficient cause for u to avoid making mockery of others agonies? but regretfully the childish attitude prevalent on u all the time has made u much proud, ignorant and heartless. It was you who used to make mockery of the miracles of Hazrat Essa a.s, now with excessive ilham and prophesies u have made a joke of yourself . The taste of Quraanic knowledge is absolutely missing from u and Jamaat. U could not present a single academic miracle which was the need of the hour. U could have written a miraculous commentary of holy Quraan that could have decided the differences and could have reformed peoples and provide guidance to the masses.
Wassalam
Humble self
Abdul Hakim Khan
Assistant Surgeon
From Tarauri, District Karnal India.

DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI vs. MGA, continued

Intro
My team and I keep summarizing and translating this book by DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI.  These were the writings that opened the box of Ahmadiyya Takfir.  This book, Zikrul Hakim, was found by my team many months ago.  We are the first group of researchers who have found this lost data.  Zikrul Hakim was a book by DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI, it was written in 1906.

Check out my other essays on this topic:

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/05/07/new-research-data-books-by-dr-abdul-hakeem-khan-have-been-found-vs-mga/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/05/09/ahle-hadith-newspaper-vs-mirza-ghulam-ahmad-and-his-situation-with-dr-abdul-hakim-khan-of-patiala/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/05/07/dr-abdul-hakeem-khan-the-famous-ahmadi-apostate-wrote-an-english-translation-of-the-quran-in-1905/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/07/15/dr-abdul-hakim-khan-predicted-mirza-ghulam-ahmads-death-the-evidence/

TO MIRZA GHULA QADIYANI
BY DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI.
Zikrul Hakim NO. 4 page-28 

IT IS VERY STRANGE THAT I WRITE TO U WITH UNAMBIGUOUS VERSES REFERENCE FROM QURAAN BUT U DONT ADDRESS THEM IN YOUR REPLY RATHER SAY THAT ACTING UPON THESE QURAANIC COMMANDS IS PROHIBITED. I HAVE BEEN REQUESTING U TIME AND AGAIN THAT I MAY BE INFORMED OF THE VERSES OF QURAAN THROUGH WHICH WHOLE UMMAT E MUHAMMADIA HAS BECOME OUT OF THE PAIL OF ISLAM IRRESPECTIVE OF THE FACT WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE BEEN PREACHED UPON. DOES THE OBLIGATION OF TABLIGH TO THE WHOLE MUSLIMIS FULFILLED BY SITTING IDLY IN QADIYAN AND PUBLISHING FEW ISHTIHARS ?. NOW THEY HAVE BECOME INFIDEL AND LIABLE TO BE CHARGE SHEETED? EVEN ALLAH SWT DECLARE THE KILLING OF INNOCENT MOMIN AS KUFR. AT THE MOMENT U R TURNING UR FACE AWAY NOT ANLY FROM QURAAN BUT FROM LOGIC AND COMMON SENSE. WHAT A TIME IT WAS WHEN U CRITICISE MOLVIS FOR EXCOMMUNICATION OF MUSLIMS AND USED TO QUOT THE SAYING OF IMAM THAT DONT EXCOMMUNICATE ONE WITH 99 REASONS OF KUFR AND ONE REASON OF IMAN. I AM ACTING ON THESE TEACHINGS BUT U HAVE DEFECTED. IT WAS YOUR SAYING THAT I GIVE PRAYERS IN RESPONSE TO ABUSES. I AM STILL ON THIS RELIGION BUT U DECLARE ME KAFIR AND MURTAD EVEN AFTER LISTENING TO MY PRAYERS AND SALAM. U ORDER MY EXIT FROM JAMAAT. U DO EXCOMMUNICATION OF UMMAT E MUHAMMADI WITHOUT REASON BUT I DONT DO THAT.

The scan

Dr. Abdul Hakim Khan Patialvi speaks vs. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (1906-1907)

Intro

Dr. Khan was fed up with MGA by 1906..MGA’s claims kept advancing, he was making bolder and bolder claims…in the below, I present a summary of Dr. Khan’s letter to Noorudin.  Dr. Khan talks about how MGA was wasting money and spending his members donations on jewelry for his wife and other ways which were a big problem.

I have written many entries on this subject.  See the below….

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/06/10/1818/
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/06/05/dr-khan-wrote-that-ahmadis-were-worhipping-mga-not-allah/
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/07/15/dr-abdul-hakim-khan-predicted-mirza-ghulam-ahmads-death-the-evidence/
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/05/07/new-research-data-books-by-dr-abdul-hakeem-khan-have-been-found-vs-mga/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/06/07/a-word-for-word-translation-of-the-writings-of-dr-abdul-hakeen-khan-of-patiala/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/05/07/dr-abdul-hakeem-khan-the-famous-ahmadi-apostate-wrote-an-english-translation-of-the-quran-in-1905/

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.wordpress.com/2017/06/09/more-data-on-dr-abdul-hakeem-patiala/

Summary

MIRZA CHARGE SHEETED BY DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI.
LETTER TO MOLVI NOORUDDIN FROM DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI. 
ZIKRUL HAKIM PAGE 368-378
Dr. Abdul Hakim Khan Patialvi was a keen follower of MGAQ, remained in his jamaat for 20 years. Then he found wrongdoings of Mirza and violation of Quraanic teachings and commandments of Allah Swt by MGAQ and his Jamaat. He made correspondence with MGAQ and Molvi Nooruddin for reform and correction but both MGAQ and Nooruddin rejected his criticism. This correspondence is very lengthy contains heavy Arabic and Persian idioms and phrases, studded with Quraanic verses and ahadis. So it is not easy to be translated in english word to word in a short time. However, I have tried to present central idea of the correspondence as under:-

Subhanallah what a logic is this, Quraan teaches us to say salam but u deny and do not say salam to me in your letter. U termed my word of Basis of salvation (madar e nijat) as vague whereas your whole letter is vague. 
I have always been the truth seeker. I am the same Abdul Hakim whose translation and commentary of Quraan has been greatly admired by Mirza Qadiyani. Whenever i read my tafseer to mgaq he could not advise a valuable points, he only said admiration. However i got valuable correction addition of points and advise from you whenever I read it over to u. He could not advise on the debate of Hazrat Suleman a.s and said I will explain it to u after consulting a book, WHICH WAS never found by him ever.

I took allegiance of Mirza in the hope of my spiritual and knowledge uplift which could not be achieved. Unfortunately, after my reform request, this very tafseer and my other books have been returned stuffed in gunny bag reached to me in a bad shape.

In the beginning Mirza sb used to say that I am only Maseel e Masih then a masih mehdi, sub ordinate prophet, better than all prophets and then Allah s son then Allah states his praise in the heavens thus committing shirk. Not only this he went to the extent of insulting other prophets and chosen persons.

His claim that earthquake in other parts of world have come due to my rejection, is also a foolish idea, how can Allah punish those with earthquake who have not even heard of MGAQ and his claims. It did not happen in the time of Harat Muhammad s.a.w that He was rejected and victimised by peoples of Makkah but peoples of other areas are killed.So Noorddin sb support of this argument of mirza does not suit to a person of your calibre.

I believe in Allah and his prophets alike as Quraan says کل امن با اللہ وملائکتہ وکتبہ ورسلہ لا نفرق بین احد من الرسلہ
But Mirza denied this verse when he said ” believing in Allah and prophets is of no use unless one does not believe in me. He published that God Says O Ahmed if u were not there I wouldn,t have created skies. He did hundreds of such things against Islam and Quraan. Few of which are described here as under:-
UNENDING BREACHES OF COMMITMENTS.
Donations were asked for, and mostly received for publishing baraheen and other books but books were not published as per commitment nor the money received as charity or Zakat was returned. Such money is being eaten up.
Excessive lies.
When there was no funds for publishing of baraheen why Reward Ishtihar of thousands of Rs were published. Why peoples were abused with Haramzada without Devine knowledge.
Abusive and obnoxious Language
Molvis who were opposing for the sake of Islam were called as waladul haram, (illegitimate), swine , cursed, satan, blind, etc etc
COMFORT LOVING AND MAN OF STOMACH
What Mirza do is that collect Chanda upto 700 or 800 per month arranged best food for himself and others, amber musk. Kewra, tonics, dry fruits and kernels are made available and used abundantly. 
I to 1.5 mound was supplied daily from Lahore during the illness of Molvi Abdul Karim. Bivi sahiba had so much jewellery that Mirza has mortgaged his garden to her for a loan of Rs. 1000 cash and jewellery worth Rs. 4000, Traveled upto Dehli in upper class of train for the sake of Bivi sahiba only. Whereas Hazrat Muhammad s.A.w. Has spent a simple life in a small house, had food after 3 days mostly. Now tell me should I follow Hazrat Muhammad s.a.w or the comfortable life of Mirza Qadiyani. 
SCHISM
Hazrat Muhammad s.a.w made the arabs pagan as brother to each others Today with his abusive language and false claims created a divide and schism that can not be repaired. 
ABANDONING HAJJ.
Should we follow mirza on the issue of Hajj or the Quraan which instruct the rich men to perform Hajj.
ASKING FOR ZAKAT FOR HIS BOOKS.
He asked for zakat money for his books and sold them on highest price.
MAKING PHOTOGRAGHS.
SHOULD WE FOLLOW THIS SUNNAH OF MIRZA.
FALSE CLAIMS FOR SELF GREATNESS
HE SAID GOD SAYS TO ME THAT U r from me and Iam from u. To me u r like my son.
CONSTRUCTION OF MINARAT.
Construction minarat in Qadiyan is useless and waste of money and against ahadis.
BAHISHTI MAQBARA.
It is absolutely against islam and Quraan and an insult to the prophets and quraam.o hadis.
INSULT OF JESUS CHRIST PBUH.
MIRZA HAS INSULTED HAZRAT ESSA A.S AND TERMED HIS MIRCLE AS JOKE.
BEGGARY
MIRZA IMPOSED MONTHLY CHANDA FOR EACH MEMBER in case of non payment his name will be struck down from bayaat.

I am ready to accept any true advise but cant tolerate with above mentioned ideas of mirza which are against Quraan o sunnah.
Humble self Abdul Hakim Khan 
Now residing at Trouri District Karnal. 

Image may contain: text
Image may contain: text
Image may contain: text
Image may contain: text

Dr. Abdul Hakim Khan predicted Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s death—the evidence

Intro
The main issue of Takfir in Ahmadiyya happened around 1906 and the controversy between MGA and Dr. Khan and the topic of whether or not a Muslim needed to accept MGA or not.  Dr. Khan was a follower of MGA before MGA claimed prophethood and before MGA ever did Takfir, in fact, by 1901, MGA was saying that the acceptance of “non-law” bearing prophets was not mandatory in Islam (See Tiryaq ul Qulub, 1902).  See the full quote here:

”””From the beginning, I have been of the view that no one becomes a kafir or a dajjal by rejecting my claim Such a one would certainly be in error and astray from the right path. I do not call him faithless but he who rejects the truth which God Almighty has disclosed to me would be in error and astray from the straight path. I do not designate anyone who believes in the Kalimah as a kafir, unless by rejecting me and calling me a kafir, he himself becomes a kafir. In this matter, my opponents have always taken a lead. they called me kafir and prepared fatwas against me. I did not take the lead in preparing fatwas against them. They would be prepared to confess that if I am a Muslim in the estimation of God Almighty, then by calling me a kafir, they themselves become one according to the fatwa of the Holy Prophetsa. Thus I do not call them kafir but they themselves fall within the purview of the fatwa of the Holy Prophetsaw” (Tiryaq-ul-Qulub, Pages 130-131, Ruhani Khazain Volume 15, Pages 432-433)””

However, MGA’s behavior had changed since then, MGA was a full fledged “ummati-Nabi” by 1906, and he wasnt holding any punches.  MGA died of cholera on May 26th, 1908, ahmadiyya leadership was quiet on the cause of death, however, the truth was that MGA had only went to Lahore in April of 1908 to seek treatment, as he was suffering from cholera and eventually died of it.

Summary
MIRZA AND DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI.
BOOK CHASHMA E MOARFAT PAGE NO 336-337
MIRZA WRITES :-
“””SIMILARLY MANY ENEMIES AMONG MUSLIMS STOOD AGAINST ME AND WERE KILLED. NOW THERE APPEARED ONE LAST ENEMY KNOWN AS DR ABDUL HAKIM KHAN PATIALVI. HE IS A DOCTOR FROM PATIALA HE CLAIMS THAT I WOULD BE KILLED IN HIS LIFE UPTO 4TH AUGUST 1908, AND THIS WOULD BE A SIGN OF HIS TRUTH FULLNESS AND HE CLAIMS IT IS A REVELATION TO ME FROM ALLAH SWT. HE DECLARES ME AS KAZZAB, DAJJAL AND KAFIR. 
HE TOOK MY ALLEGIANCE AND REMAINED MY FOLLOWER FOR 20 YEARS.BUT WHEN I GAVE HIM AN ADVISE HE DEVIATED. THE ADVISE WAS GIVEN JUST FOR ALLAH,S SAKE WHICH WAS THAT HE WAS OF THE FAITH THAT ONE CAN GET DELIVERANCE IN THE WORLD HEREAFTER WITHOUT ACCEPTING HAZRAT MUHAMMAD S.A.W. I TOLD HIM THAT THIS BELIEF IS AGAINST ISLAM AND MAJORITY OF THE ELDERS OF ISLAM.BUT HE TURNED A DEAF EAR TO IT, FINALLY I REMOVED HIM FROM MY JAMMAT.THEN HE PROPHESIED THAT I WOULD BE KILLED BY 4TH AUGUST 1908 IN HIS LIFE TIME. BUT COUNTERING HIS PROPHESY, GOD HAS INFORMED ME THAT HE HIMSELF WOULD RECEIVE AZAB AND GOD WOULD KILL HIM AND WILL PROTECT ME FROM HIS EVIL.SO THIS IS THE CASE WHICH IS NOW IN THE COURT OF ALLAH FOR DECISION.”””

The scan

Ahle Hadith newspaper vs. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad and his situation with Dr. Abdul Hakim Khan of Patiala

Intro
Dr. Abdul Hakim Khan of Patiala was kicked out of Ahmadiyya in 1906 by MGA, however, he was able to get MGA to claim that any Muslim who rejected MGA was a Kafir, indefinitely. Nonetheless, some of the local newspapers that were hostile to Ahmadis wrote about the death of MGA and some of the counter prophecies which led up to MGA’s death in Lahore.

“But, we expected this to happen soon, as had been announced by Dr. Abdul Hakim of Patiala. The doctor had stated, ‘My revelation concerning Mirza of Qadian, which may kindly be published, is that: (1) The Mirza will die on the 21st day of Saavan, 1965 (4th August, 1908) of a fatal disease. (2) A distinguished woman of the family of Mirza shall also die.’ [Weekly Ahle Hadith: 15.5.1908]. However, we cannot refrain from saying what is true. Had the doctor stopped at what he had stated before, that is, his prediction of Mirza’s death within fourteen months and not fixed a specific date as he has done then those objections could have never been raised as are being raised today by the Paisa Akhbar of the 27th, wherein it is stated that had the prophecy been left as, ‘up to the 21st of Saavan’ and not altered to, ‘on the 21st of Saavan’ it would have, indeed, been wonderful. But alas, his revelation that Mirza will die on the 21st of Saavan, that is 4th of August, has been published in the Ahle Hadith issue of 15th May, 1908. We wish that he would have left his earlier revelations unaltered, without giving a specific date. Then there could have been no excuse.”

(Ahle Hadith, 12 June 1908)

Zikrul Hakim Numbers 4 and 5, by Dr. Abdul Hakeem Khan of Patiala vs. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad

Attached…

Zikrul Hakim No 4

Zikrul Hakim No 5

The life and death of Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti


Intro
Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti was born in 1858 (see Dard, page 816, 2008 online edition, the original was published in 1948), he died on Oct. 11th, 1905 (see english ROR, November-1905 pages 446-447).  He was a follower of MGA from roughly 1889 to his death in 1905.  We don’t talk about people’s death normally, however, in the case of Ahmadiyya, we are forced to, since all Ahmadi’s wish a miserable death upon us.  Moreover, MGA wished a miserable death on all his critics.  Hence, we are forced to write about these types of situations.

MGA knew Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti since the 1860’s
They never met in this era, however, MGA must have known some relatives of Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti.

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2016/12/24/mirza-ghulam-ahmad-knew-maulvi-abdul-karim-since-the-mid-1860s-in-sialkot/

Pre–1889, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti was influenced heavily by Sir Syed, before he met MGA
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2016/10/24/noorudin-and-abdul-karim-were-influenced-by-sir-syed/

Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti takes MGA’s bait in 1889, he is Ahmadi #43, Mirza Bashir Ahmad lies about this
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/07/17/ahmadiyya-leadership-lied-about-the-first-bait-ceremony-in-1889/

1889–1890, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti was an employee of Nooruddin
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/01/02/mufti-muhammad-sadiq-was-a-student-of-noorudin-pre-1891/

1891, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti and his wife moves into MGA’s home
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/06/27/maulvi-abdul-kareem-lived-exclusively-with-mga-on-the-3rd-floor-of-mgas-house/

1891, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti, Amrohi and Noorudin become the imams of the mosques at Qadian
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/?s=never+led

1891, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti’s young wife
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2018/03/24/the-wife-of-maulvi-abdul-karim-sialkoti-zainab-bibi/

1891–Dr. Basharat Ahmad (who eventually became a Lahori-Ahmadi) learned of Ahmadiyya through Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti.
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/07/17/how-i-became-an-ahmadi-by-dr-basharat-ahmad-the-famous-lahori-ahmadi-who-wrote-mujadid-e-azam/

Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti was also a ghost writer and editor and speech giver
He used to translate Mirza’s writings into Farsi and Arabic, and also read out his speeches and sermons. He has been variously described as one of the two ‘angels’ on whose shoulders the Messiah landed.

After taking bai’at, Maulvi Abdul Karim frequently visited Qadian to spend time in the company of the Promised Messiah and to benefit from his spiritual and learned discourses. He made it a point to accompany the Promised Messiah wherever he went for dissemination of Islam and the true teachings of the Qur’an. We find him present in Ludhiana in July 1891 during the debate between Maulvi Muhammad Hussain Batalvi and the Promised Messiah; similarly in October 1891 during the Promised Messiah’s speech in Jamia Masjid Dehli, and during the debates by the Promised Messiah with Maulvi Nazeer Hussain Dehlvi, and the written debate with Maulvi Muhammad Bashir Bhopali. He was one amongst those seventy persons who attended the first Jalsa Salana (Annual Gathering) which was held in Qadian from 27 to 29 December, 1891, and thereafter he accompanied the Promised Messiah on his visit to Lahore in January 1892 and his visit to Sialkot in February 1892.

1896, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti delivers the famous lecture, “Philosophy of the Teachings of Islam”, however, Nooruddin is one of the judges
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/11/25/some-brief-notes-on-the-philosophy-of-the-teachings-of-islam-aka-islami-usool-ki-falasifi-1896/

1898
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2018/06/27/lecture-in-1898-by-maulvi-abdul-karim-of-sialkot-on-claims-and-work-of-hazrat-mirza-ghulam-ahmad/

1900, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti announces MGA’s prophethood and argues with Syed Muhammad Ahsan Amrohi
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2016/09/30/maulvi-abdul-kareem-claims-prophethood-per-mga-maulvi-amrohi-disagrees/

Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti went totally blind by roughly 1902
Ahmadi biographers have written that Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti was slowly going blind.  If you see his pictures from roughly 1900, he is wearing glasses, however, soon thereafter, all of his pictures show him to be wearing glasses, which are an indication that he had totally went blind by roughly 1902.

1903 era—Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti’s wife?
Not much is written about the wife of Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti, she makes one appearance in the literature of Ahmadiyya, this is in roughly the 1903 era.  She competes with the wife of Noorudin, in terms of who does MGA love more?  Noorudin or Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti.  Further, where are his children?  He seems to either have had NO children or they disappeared.

1904, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti is the official Ahmadi speech giver, he gives speeches on behalf of MGA all over the Punjab
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/06/12/lecture-sialkot-was-delivered-by-maulvi-abdul-kareem-not-mga-1904/

August–Oct 1905
While on his deathbed, and since he was totally blind, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti hit his head on a window and his head was split open.

https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2018/03/08/the-agonizing-death-of-maulvi-abdul-karim-sialkoti-1905/

1905, Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti dies of plague, MGA refuses to visit him on his deathbed
He fell ill in August of 1905, and died on 11 October 1905, probably of the plague, as Mirza did not visit him on his deathbed despite his request. On December 27, 1905, his body was exhumed and re-buried in the Bahishti Maqbara with new funeral prayers.

Notice of his death appeared in the Review of Religions. Abdul Kaim’s death was apparently caused by a huge carbuncle that was on his back..which later turned into a disease of pleurodynia. People have wondered if pleurodynia had anything connection with the plague?

Pages 446–447 http://www.aaiil.org/text/articles/revi … sh1905.pdf

Muhammad Ali died when Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti died

The Promised Messiah, who had spent those sleepless nights in prayers for his recovery for over two months and had procured every kind of medicine and food required by the doctors for his treatment and recovery, submitted to the will of God and became composed and asked Maulvi Muhammad Ali and Dr. Yaqub Beg, who were weeping, to stop crying. Inna illahi wa inna ilaih rajeoon. The next morning the Promised Messiah led Maulvi Abdul Karim’s funeral prayer and he was temporarily buried in general a graveyard of Qadian.

http://www.aaiil.org/text/articles/hope/2008/hope200802_abdulkarimsialkotipromisedmessiah.pdf
 
page 5

After Maulvi Abdul Karim died, MGA made disparaging remarks about him

“Suddenly on the 10 October 1905 Maulvi Abdul Karim suffered an attack of pleurisy and high fever. His body temperature rose to 106 degree. This condition continued for one and half days and finally he passed away on 11 October 1905.”

 

see http://www.aaiil.org/text/articles/hope/2008/hope200802_abdulkarimsialkotipromisedmessiah.pdf

After the death of Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2018/03/06/per-mga-noorudin-was-worth-1000-maulvi-abdul-karim-sialkotis/

Dr. Khan, the Ahmadi apostate, mentions the death of Maulvi Abdul Karim Sialkoti
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/07/24/dr-abdul-hakim-khan-patialvi-mentions-the-death-of-maulvi-abdul-karim-in-his-correspondence-with-mga/

Related Essays and Links

http://www.aaiil.org/text/articles/reviewofreligions/raw/reviewreligionsenglish1905.pdf

Tags

#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

An english translation of the Quran by official Ahmadiyya sources in 1905, by Dr. Khan, who would end up leaving Ahmadiyya shortly thereafter



Intro

The research team here at the blog has found the first ever english translation of the Quran by Ahmadiyya sources.  It was written by Dr. Abdul Hakeem Khan, this is before he argued with MGA on the topic of salvation and verse 2:62.  In fact, the Review of Religions (see Oct-1905, page 404) even posted an ad wherein they were marketing this translation to the world as an official Ahmadiyya translation and etc.  Dr. Khan was an Ahmadi for 20+ years up to 1906, he saw MGA as his peer even before MGA was accepting Bait in 1889.  MGA slipped-up in this exchange and told Dr. Khan that all Muslims who rejected him (MGA) were Kafirs.  This would prompt MGA’s son, Mirza Basheer-uddin Mahmud Ahmad to do Takfir in 1911 and continue to do it until 1922.

The biological birth of Esa (as)
On page 112 of this Tafsir, the Ahmadi author argues that Esa (As) was born from biological parents, this seems to confirm what MGA and his team wrote in 1891, in Izala Auham, i.e. that Esa (As) was raised by his father, Joseph.  Muhammad Ali split in 1914 and his Tafsir was published in 1917 wherein he made the same argument, i.e. that Esa (As) was fathered biologically by Joseph and the Qadianis never objected.

MGA issued a fatwa in 1904 which is opposite of the Lahori belief
Nooruddin argued with MGA on this topic.  MGA then issued a fatwa on this topic, read it here:
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/?s=birth+of+esa

As soon as MGA died, Noorudin started writing that Esa (As) had a father again
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/?s=birth+of+esa

Mirza Tahir Ahmad called Maryam (ra) as a Hermaphradite
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/10/07/mirza-tahir-ahmad-called-esa-ass-mother-a-hermaphrodite/

The missing link??
We are missing the 2nd Khalifa’s comments on this topic.  We are missing all statements from the Qadianis from 1914 to 1984.

Free Download
The Holy Quran with a Commentary by Dr Abdul Hakim

Up ↑