ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

Intro
This is an interesting book, we haven’t totally evaluated it yet. However, it seems to have lots of controversial information. MGA wrote about the child-marriage of Aisha and many other related topics. The Arya Samaj hindus seem to have written an analysis of the marriages of Muhammad (saw). MGA and his team responded with “The Arya Religion” (1895). The second edition of this book was published in 1903 (from the Lahori-Ahmaid website, aryadharam. This was a small part in the overall beef that MGA started with the Arya Samaj in the early 1880’s. Lekh Ram came soon thereafter. In this book, MGA complained that his God and prophet were being unnecessarily ridiculed and it should be against the law, however, MGA himself insulted the God of Christians in this very, in fact, he used Hindu writings vs. Jesus Christ as he called him a drunkard and a fornicator. In this book, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad specifically wanted European prostitutes to be given to British soldiers in India. MGA wrote sexual poetry in this book too, he made a mockery of the Hindu concept of Niyog, this was so embarrassing for Ahmadi’s, they have created an introduction to the book in Ruhani Khuzain and allege that MGA’s father-in-law (Mir Nasir Nawab) wrote the poem (which is a lie, see scans and commentary in the below). At the bottom of page 77, the poem ends, and MGA signs off

In this book, MGA seems to have endorsed the concept of Nikah-Muta and abrogation. Arya Dharam comprises of pages 1–110 in RK-10. It seems that MGA and his team of writers wrote that Adam (as) was the first man on Earth in this book. However, by 1908, he seems to have changed his position, either that or Ahmadi’s edited, in Malfuzat (published in the 1960’s from Rabwah), it is written how MGA had a conversation with English scholar of Astronomy, Professor Wragge and said that Adam (as) wasn’t the first man.

It should be also noted that MGA allowed money from prostitutes to be given in the way of Islam. Continue reading ““Arya Dharam” or “The Arya Religion” (1895) by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad” →

Intro
Watch my video on this herein, and my Tik Tok and instagram. MGA was so far gone, he endorsed an idea wherein european prostitutes should be brought in to service the British soldiers who were toiling in India. Arya Darham is the same book that contains sexual poetry and etc. In this same book, MGA wrote about the child-marriage of Aisha and many other related topics. The Arya Samaj hindus seem to have written an analysis of the marriages of Muhammad (saw). MGA and his team responded with “The Arya Religion” (1895). The second edition of this book was published in 1903. This was a small part in the overall beef that MGA started with the Arya Samaj in the early 1880’s. Lekh Ram came soon thereafter. In this book, MGA complained that his God and prophet were being unnecessarily ridiculed and it should be against the law, however, MGA himself insulted the God of Christians in this very book, in fact, he used Hindu writings vs. Jesus Christ as he called him a drunkard and a fornicator.
Continue reading “Mirza Ghulam Ahmad specifically wanted europeans prostitutes to be given to British soldiers in India” →

Intro
Ahmadi’s don’t follow the writings of MGA in many cases. The case of Adam (as) is yet another. In 1895, MGA wrote in Arya Dharam that Eve was created from the rib of Adam (as)(see Sahih Bukhari in the below). 2 years later in 1898, in Kitab ul Barriya, MGA was claiming that he was born with a twin sister, however, this seems to be a lie. It seems that MGA was creating a back story. About 10 years later, MGA was asserting that Adam (as) was created as a twin (see the full quote in the below). Later on, in Malfuzat, MGA and his team of writers seems to have given additional data on Adam (as) not being the first man. Watch my video on this here. This belief is totally unislamic. In the Quran, 2:35-36, proves that Adam (as) was living in Jannah (heaven) with Allah. Allah then created Eve. Allah then sent them both to Earth, through the 7 heavens.

The Ahmadiyya belief that Adam (as) wasn’t the first human comes from 1947 and the publishing of Tafsir-e-Kabeer. The introduction to that commentary had a long entry wherein the Khalifa (Mirza Basheer ud Din Mahmud Ahmad) wrote that before Adam (as) there were humans already on the planet (in 1985, this intro was turned into a separate book, “Introduction to The Study of the Holy Quran and published from the UK, you can view the 2016 online english edition herein). He continued and claimed that the humans who were already on the planet were Jinn, since they hadn’t evolved fully. This is blasphemy and totally against Islam. Obviously, the Qadiani-Ahmadi’s were indirectly agreeing with the theory of evolution (Darwinism). They took all of this from Sir Syed Ahmad Khan who most likely denied the traditional creation story in Islam.”

The islamic perspective is as follows, Adam (as) and Eve were the two first humans on Earth. Allah them brought animals, fruit, sugar, chocolate, all in pairs. This is what the verses of the Quran mean when taken together. There are about 9 verses in the Quran which refer to Allah creating in pairs. However, this doesn’t contradict the idea that Adam (as) was not born a twin. Tafsir ibn Kathir tells us that Allah created Eva (as) from the rib (bone and blood) of Adam (as). Allah created everything from dust, its all the same ingredients, just look at the table of elements, they prove that Allah can make a human from another human easily. Tafsir Ibn Kathir is an amazing classical book on Tafsir. Ibn Kathir tells us that Allah created a single soul, i.e. Adam (as) and then created Hawa aka Eva from the rib of Adam (as).  

Verses which prove that humans were made in pairs after Adam (as) was sent to Earth are as follows: 78:8—–“””And We created you in pairs”” and 53:45, 51:49, 55:52, 43:12, 42:11, 36:36, 35:11 and 39:6.

Continue reading “In 1947, the Qadiani-Ahmadi’s began claiming that humans existed on Earth before Adam (as) of the Quran” →

Intro
In 1895, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad wrote that Nikah-Muta was only allowed for 3 days and then stopped altogether by Muhammad (saw)(See Arya Dharam). MGA also asserted that Nikah-Muta isn’t in the quran or hadith, MGA also wished that Nikah Muta was still available (see the scan in the below). However, this is a bold face lie, 4:24 of the Quran covers the topic of Nikah-Muta as well as many Sahih-hadith from Bukhari. By 1988, and via Malik Ghulam Farid’s famous 5-volume english commentary of the Quran, Ahmadi’s denied Nikah Muta altogether, and thus, contradicted MGA. It is unclear what the 2nd Khalifa wrote in Tafsir i Kabir and Tafsir i Saghir. Continue reading “Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s position on Nikah mut’ah?” →

Intro
The Akhbar-e-‘Am newspaper of Lahore was started in 1870 by a Kashmiri pundit, Mukand Lal. (See “Lineages of the Present: Ideology and Politics in Contemporary South Asia” By Aijaz Ahmad, page 124). Dard tells us (page 59, ‘”Life of Ahmad”)that MGA read Akhbar-e-‘Am in the latter stage of his life. However, MGA sent letters to the Akhbar-e-‘Am as early as 1885. It should be noted that it is also written as Akhbar-e-‘Aam (See Tadhkirah). In 1895, MGA quoted (and agreed with this quote) the Akhbar-e-‘Aam in Arya Dharam and in 1907 in Haqiqatul Wahy, thus proving that MGA supported them and vice versa.  Continue reading “The Akhbar-e-‘Am of Lahore and its support of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad” →

Intro
In 1907, in MGA’s famous book, Haqiqatul Wahy, MGA claimed that Adam (as) was born as a twin. This seems to be the first time that MGA used his argument in his career. We haven’t found any instances before this. This belief is totally unislamic. In the Quran, 2:35-36, proves that Adam (as) was living in Jannah (heaven) with Allah. Allah then created Eve. Allah then sent them both to Earth, through the 7 heavens.

Historically, in 1898, in Kitab ul Barriya, MGA was claiming that he was born with a twin sister, however, this seems to be a lie. It seems that MGA was creating a back story. About 10 years later, MGA was asserting that Adam (as) was created as a twin (see the full quote in the below). Later on, in Malfuzat, MGA and his team of writers seems to have given additional data on Adam (as) not being the first man. Watch my video on this here. MGA also discussed this in Tiryaq ul Qulub (see the scans in the below).
Continue reading “Mirza Ghulam Ahmad claimed that Adam (as) was born a twin (in pairs), totally unislamic” →

Intro
I was under the impression that MGA deviated from Islam in 1891, upon his claim of being the long awaited Messiah.  However, new research work has proven that MGA began denying some of the basics of Islam in the mid-1880’s.

The Quote
1895 in Arya Dharam:

Urdu Transliteration—-“”””jasay Hazrat Hawa Hazrat Adam ki pasli sa nikali gae aisay he har yak larkay ki joroo us ki pasli sa nikali gae ho””””

“””Just like Hazrat Hawa was created by rib of Hazrat Adam same as each boy’s wife was created from his rib.( rk vol 10 Aariya Darham page 39)”””

Conclusions
MGA and Noorudin were conspiring together to create a religious business as early as 1882. They seem to have slowly changed their beliefs about Islam without giving proper announcements.  It is likely that Sir Syed also denied the “RIB” story and MGA simply stole the new argument and passed it off as his own.  In fact, all the abrahamic religions have this in common.  They all believe that women were made from the rib of a man.

Intro
MGA contradicted himself many times. Most likely because he had multiple ghost-writers. In a recent catch, we see MGA and his team of writers trying to assert that Adam (as) was born as a twin…and Eve or Hawa was the female twin of Adam (as) (nauzobillah).
Continue reading “MGA’s strange beliefs on the birth of Adam (as)” →