We have proved that MGA died of cholera. Even Farquhar wrote the same in 1915. This is also the last words of MGA as reported by MGA’s father-in-law, Mir Nasir Nawab in the 1920’s as he narrated to Shaikh Ali Yacub Irfani in his autobiography. This Khutbah by Noorudin was his second Friday Sermon after becoming the Khalifa at Qadian, in it, he says MGA might have died of cholera. Continue reading “The reason that Ahmadi’s won’t admit that MGA died of cholera is because MGA told his enemies that they would die of cholera”
We have found an interesting article from the Al-Hakam of June 14th, 1908. This article seems to be a report of the Friday sermon of Noorudin, at the Aqsa mosque in Qadian. Nooruddin admits that the enemies of Ahmadiyya were alleging MGA had died of cholera. In fact, he even said that if MGA had died of cholera, that he still died the death of a martyr, however, he seems to have forgot that MGA had recently told Maulvi Sanaullah that he would die of cholera and that it was a curse from god.
However, we have found independent sources (the Vakil newspaper) in this time frame that claimed that MGA had died of cholera, in Urdu as Haiza. Even Farquhar wrote the same in 1915. This is also the word that was used by MGA’s father-in-law, Mir Nasir Nawab in the 1920’s as he narrated to Shaikh Ali Yacub Irfani his autobiography. This Khutbah by Noorudin was his second Friday Sermon after becoming the Khalifa at Qadian. Further, MGA was sitting on mobile toilet (chowkee) just minutes before he died, he died on Brandereth Road in Lahore. You can read MGA’s death story here from Ahmadi sources only. Continue reading “New data found on the death of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad via cholera from June 1908”
A few months ago, the Ahmadi trolls chased Dr. Shadee Elmasry, they called him a terrorist and asked the U.S. govt. to investigate him. This is the common Ahmadiyya tactic vs. their critics. They did the same to Professor Johnathan Brown and basically all Sunni/Shia leaders here in America. About a year ago, Dr. Elmasry recorded a lecture on Prophethood, we came across this by chance, we have cut out the specific part of this lecture wherein he explains the Ahmadiyya. The full video is also posted. It is important to note that he mentions the death of MGA on the toilet, you can read that full story here, and fully and properly referenced. Continue reading “Dr. Shadee Elmasry explains the falsity of Ahmadiyya prophethood, and how MGA died on the toilet, death by diarrhea/cholera”
Ahmadiyya sources should never be trusted, we should always be looking to verify their information. When MGA died in May of 1908, the Ahmadiyya editing team began backdating his year of birth to 1836 or 1837, which was used from June of 1908 until the 1930’s when it was officially moved to 1835, even the Lahori-Ahmadi adopted this DOB. The essay in the below, was written by Maulana Abu Kalamazad, in 1908, he seemed to be unaware that MGA had claimed prophethood.
The English Review of Religions of June 1908, did not mention the obituary of the newspaper Wakil (pronounced Vakil), the reason was that Maulana Abu Kalamazad claimed that MGA died of cholera, which was well known, even the Ahmadi Khalifa (Maulvi Noorudin) wrote the same in June of 1908. Even Farquhar wrote the same in 1915. This is also the word that was used by MGA’s father-in-law, Mir Nasir Nawab in the 1920’s as he narrated to Shaikh Ali Yacub Irfani his autobiography. In 1918, Ahmadi’s told Walter that MGA had died of intestine trouble, which is proof that Ahmadi’s lie openly and are willingly ordered to cover-up the truth and thus, the story was changed in Ahmadiyya history. Nowadays, Ahmadi’s are willfully ignoring the full facts of what Maulana Abu Kalamazad wrote about MGA. It should be noted that Maulana Abu Kalamazad also believed that Esa (As) had died and would never return to Earth, he also disbelieved in the hadith about the Mahdi, that’s probably why he had a good view of MGA in 1908. In 1919, he famously wrote that Ahmadi’s had gone too far by ascribing prophethood to MGA. By 1936, however, his attitude had totally changed, he called both the Qadiani and Lahori branches as mis-guided. Also, read about Abdul Majeed Salik and his testimony about Maulana Abu Kalamazad and MGA’s death. In 1914, he called Ahmadi’s as “Qadiani’s or “Lahori’s” and wrote about the split in his newspaper, the Al-Hilal.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________Ahmadiyya sources purposely never quoted the Vakil of Amritsar
The academic dishonesty of Ahmadis is well known. They purposely lie and edit their own writings and refuse to acknowledge all the sources on any given topic. In this specific situation, when MGA died, Ahmadiyya leaders quoted many newspapers as they commented on the death of MGA, however, they purposely left out the Vakil. However, we have now found it…
Summary of this scan
The Vakil Amritsar dated 30th May 1908 couple of days after the death of Mirza. Its editor name mentioned on top is Dost Muhammad Shahid. Remember per Seerat ul Mahdi Mirza used to call for, this News paper from Amritsar and MGA was a regular reader of this paper in his life time.
The front page of the paper carries article on the death of Mirza as under:-
The Vakil Amritsar dated 30th May 1908
“”””LATE MIRZA GHULAM AHMAD
The day of 26 May 1908 will be remembered in latest religious history of India for long time when at about 10 am Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiyani died of cholera disease or as per saying of few due to some other disease. Late Mirza was staying at Lahore for the treatment of his wife and change of climate but the powerful order of Allah and time of departure which rich and poor common men and Nabi of great caliber have to face, has come for a person who by his amazing claims had created a tremor amongst religious ranks.”””
Some newspaper reports that are important
“””””Huzoor (Mirza Ghulam) could not talk two hours before death. Dr. Mirza Yaqoob Baig and Dr. Syed Mohammad Hussein Shah were the attending physicians. Huzoor asked for paper and wrote on it: ‘I have too much dryness. I can’t talk.’ and some other words which could not be read.””””” (Al-Fazl, Vol. 25, No. 274, November 24, 1937)
“”””As his condition became precarious, we stayed by him and continued treatment, but his pulse stopped by 10:15 A.M., on the 26th May, 1908 he breathed his last.”””” (Al-Hakam, May 28, 1908)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________Links and Related Essays
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiapartheid #Ahmadiyyat #rabwah #qadian #meetthekhalifa #muslimsforpeace #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #nolifewithoutkhalifa #AhmadiMosqueattack #AhmadiyyaPersecution #Mosqueattack #trueislam #atifmian #cholera #deathbycholera
MGA always prayed for the death of his critics, however, his own children died off in front of MGA’s own eyes, his mullahs died also, lots of ahmadis died or left Ahmadiyya in MGA’s lifetime. In this specific case, MGA had made a the famous Musleh Maud prophecy on February 20th, 1886, that his wife was pregnant and she would give birth to a promised son, he followed this up with another announcement on March 22nd, 1886, and another on April 8th, 1886, and re-iterated the same language, i.e., that a son would be born to MGA very soon. However a girl was born on April 15, 1886 and MGA was embarrassed for failing in his prediction. A storm of ridicule and abuse was raised by the religous communities of British-India (muslims, christians and hindu’s) against MGA. The Christian paper Nur Afshan (dated June 3rd,1886), Pt. Lekhram of the Arya Samaj (vide his Ishtihar dated, April 25th, 1886), Nabi Bakhsh, a Muslim of Lahore, and others declared that the prophecy was falsified by the birth of the daughter.
Muslims began to become weary of MGA at this point (1886) (see Dard, page 192). Qadiani-Ahmadiyya records were silent on the death of Ismat, which we all know happened in 1891. However, we have recently found a reference to this story which prompted us to dig deeper.
This reference is from one of the oldest biographies on the life of MGA, its “Seeratul-masih -maoud by yaqub ali irfani which was published roughly in 1915. He also later on wrote the biography of Mir Nasir Nawab, wherein MGA’s admission of death by cholera was recorded. The book was later on edited by Ahmadiyya leadership, however, we have the original. Interestingly enough, the Lahori-Ahmadi biographer, Dr. Basharat Ahmad also wrote the same, i.e. that Ismat died of cholera in 1891, (see page, 87, http://www.muslim.org/bookspdf/tgr1/tgr1.pdf).
Continue reading “Mirza Ghulam Ahmad’s daughter, “Ismat” died of cholera in 1891–at age 6″
MGA was taking Chlorodyne just a few hours before his death. Chlorodyne was the main medicine in the world to cure #cholera. MGA and his doctors knew that he had cholera.
A few hours later, Dr. Mirza Yacub Beg reports that MGA was forced to sit on a chokee (shitter). MGA was given an injection directly into his heart as he about to die. MGA most likely died at 3-4am on May 26th, 1908, on Brandereth Road in Lahore. Molvi Abdur Rehman was there with MGA on brandereth road when MGA died. Continue reading “Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was taking Chlorodyne (a cure for cholera) just before his death”
It is thought by many that MGA died of cholera in 1908. Farquhar wrote about it here, and we know that Ahmadi authors were all silent on the cause of death for 20 years. Then, Hyat-e-Nasir was published in 1927 and the populace of India was convinced, thru MGA’s own testimony that he had cholera, plus the symptoms and the quick death (within 2 hours). Further research is proving that the entire “Train-Story” seems to have been fabricated after 1927, since Muhammad Ali wrote in roughly 1917 that MGA’s body was carried all the way to Qadian. Moreover, Ahmadi authors never mentioned Dr. Sutherland and any certificate until the 1930’s. Further, there are 4 early biographies on the life of MGA which are missing from the official records. Dr. Basharat Ahmad mentions them in his famous collection, “Mujadid-e-Azam”. Also, no one has pulled the data from the Urdu-ROR or the Hakam and Badr of 1908.
Some additional sources that I am researching
How fast were trains in 1908?
John Nicol Farquhar (6 April 1861 – 17 July 1929) was a Scottish educational missionary to Calcutta, and an Orientalist. He is one of the pioneers who popularised the Fulfilment theology in India that Christ is the crown of Hinduism, though, Fulfilment thesis in Bengal was built on foundation originally laid in Madras by William Miller. He authored several books on Hinduism, notably, The Crown of Hindustan, A Primer of Hinduism, Gita and Gospel, and many alike. Continue reading “Farquhar claims that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad died of Cholera (1915)”
MGA died very abruptly on May 26th, 1908 in Lahore, British-India. Rumors had spread that MGA died of cholera, in fact, the streets of Lahore were buzzing with the news that MGA had died overnight and it must have been because of cholera. Muslims showed up to where MGA was held up (Ahmadiyya buildings) and began challenging MGA to debates and etc (see page 22-23, Last Days of MGA by Nasir Ahmad, Lahori-Ahmadi, http://aaiil.org/text/books/others/nasirahmad/lastdaysdeathmga/lastdaysdeathmga.pdf).
The evening of May 25th, 1908
MGA went out with his wife for an evening stroll in their horse carriage. MGA lived the life of a bon vivant (see page 23, Nasir Ahmad). MGA died the very next morning and his father in law tells us as follows:
“The night his holiness fell ill, I was sleeping in my room. When his illness grew severe, they woke me up. I went over to his holiness and found him in great pain. He addressed me saying: ‘I have been stricken with cholera.’ After this, he did not utter a single intelligible and coherent word till he died on Monday, after ten O’clock in the morning.”
(Hayat-i-Nasir, P. 14) Statement of Mir Nasir Nawab in his autobiography compiled by Shaikh Yaqoob Ali Irfani Qadiani. He was the editor of the Al-Hakam magazine, and thus a very good source of information in terms of Ahmadiyya.
Muslims rushed the house where MGA’s body was
The Muslims who were camped out in front of Ahmadiyya buildings seem to have gotten the word that MGA was dead (see page 28, Nasir Ahmad). They immediately came and knocked on the door and a mob scene developed. The British police then showed up and most likely began beating Muslims and forcing them to disperse. The Muslims then dispersed to Islamia College, which was only across the street and began raising a hue and cry that MGA had died of cholera. They then proceeded to follow the Ahmadis that were trying to transport MGA’s body via train back to Qadian. As the the procession approached the railway station, it was reported to the railway authorities that MGA had died of cholera and thus shouldnt be allowed to contaminate a train and etc.
Ahmadis called in a friend to fabricate a death certificate for MGA
When information about this reached Ahmadis, Shaikh Rahmatullah, a leading businessman of Lahore and devoted follower of the Promised Messiah, hastened to Dr. Sutherland, principal of the Medical College, Lahore, who had attended the Founder close to the end, and obtained from him a medical certificate to the effect that the death was due to diarrhea brought on by mental exertion, and not cholera as alleged by the opponents.
The medical certificate was pure forgery
Ahmadis had lots of connections, they could pay for a Britisher to sign anything for them, in fact, all a Britisher had to hear was about how the Mirza family helped the British in 1857…and thats it..the britishers were willing to sign anything for MGA, and they didnt really care if more Indians died…since whites and indians didn’t travel in the same train-cars anyways…
MGA’s death is a total cover-up job by the Ahmadiyya. They have no shame at all whatsoever. In fact, the second edition of Hyat e Nasir was printed a few years after the first edition and Ahmadis edited these comments by the father-in-law of MGA, who had already died by the time the 2nd edition was published. This proves that Ahmadis will go at any length to lie in their attempt to promote MGA and his family.
MGA was an opium addict, the proof is in his denial. See my essays on that topic. Nonetheless, he most likely took too much opium and had an overdose.
Below is a scanned attempt by Ahmadis at accusing their critics of mis-quoting, however, these Ahmadis dont know that it was Ahmadis who edited the book, not their critics.
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiapartheid #Ahmadiyyat #rabwah #qadian #meetthekhalifa #muslimsforpeace #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #nolifewithoutkhalifa #AhmadiMosqueattack #AhmadiyyaPersecution #Mosqueattack #trueislam #atifmian