Intro
In 1902, the Al-Hakam newspaper reported that a few months earlier, on Dec-24-1901, MGA criticized the God of the Christians by describing Jesus (as) as a fetus and feeding of off menstrual blood and how nasty of a process human birth is and scoffing at how Christians believe that their God (Jesus) went through this sick process (see the full English translation and Urdu transliteration in the below)(See Malfuzat, V-2, page 454, 2022 Urdu edition
Al-Hakam, vol. 6, number 4, January 31, 1902, pp. 3-3).

This entire topic was discussed recently by Razi vs. Imtiaz, Razi countered and quoted a poem by Ibn Qayyim entitled, “Ighaathat Allahfaan”, however, technically, a fetus doesn’t feed off of menstrual blood, this proven (see the tweets of Adnan Rashid vs. Tahir Nasser).

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________1901
Malfuzat, V-2, page 454, 2022 Urdu edition
Al-Hakam, vol. 6, number 4, January 31, 1902, pp. 3-3
Speech was said on December 24, 1901.

“”Can human intellect believe that a child of a woman who stays in the womb for nine months and eats menstrual blood and is born from the private part, crying, like normal children, is God?””

Transliteration
“”Kya aaql maan leti hai keh aik aurat ka bacha Jo no mehane tak pait mein rahe aur khon-i-haiz kha de aur akhir aam bachoon ki tarah chilata howa sharam-gah se paida ho wo khuda hota hai?””

Scans

 

 

 

______________________________________________________________________________________________
Ighaathat Allahfaan, Volume 2, by Ibn Qayyim, 751H

Translation of the scan in the below from Ibn Qayyim
And how did the angels deprive him of their protection when they had his cry?

And what a wonder that a grave holds a god, and even more wondrous is an abdomen that held him
He stayed therein for 9 months, in the darkness (and) menstruation fed him
And tore through the genital area as a small newborn, weak ( opening his mouth to be fed from the breast?) brackets coz literal translation won’t make sense….literally it says “opening to the breast his mouth”

Scan

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tweets

https://x.com/MrAdnanRashid/status/1813962028090114364

Tahir on X: “@MrAdnanRashid Lmao. Are you joking? What is menstrual blood? Where do you think it comes from 😂 When there’s a foetus, the blood that would otherwise be menstrual blood, feeds the foetus via the placental barrier. La Haula…” / X

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s

Ighaathatul-Lahfaan min Masaayad ash-Shaytaan – ibn al-Qayyim (sifatusafwa.com)

Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya – Wikipedia

The “Al-Hakam” newspaper of the Ahmadiyya Movement – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags

#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #ahmadianswers #mirzaghulamahmad #qadiani #qadianism