Intro
It seems that a few days ago, a Muslim Tiktoker named @Docf61 engaged respected Ibrahim Noonan sahib on TikTok on the topic Christianity going astray before Jesus’ (as) death, assuming that Eisa (as) lived up to age 120 and via the Ahmadiyya argument on 5:116 of the Quran (5:117 in the Kadiani Koran). In fact, in the recent debate with between Sheikh Asrar Rashid and Maulvi Razi, this was brought up too! MGA made this contradictory argument at (RK, V-19, p. 65)(See also, “Kishti-e-Nuh, online English edition, page 105)(RK V-8p. 29). The Muslim argument is that if Eisa (as) died at 120 C.E., Paul was already dead and had already led Christians astray and Eisa (as) was still alive and living in India. This is a huge contradiction.
In 2011, while on Rah-e-Huda, Ibrahim Noonan authenticated the Gospel of Thomas and the account of Thomas being in India while Jesus (as) was alive and meeting Jesus (as), in roughly 40 C.E., Noonan then argues that St. Thomas travelled to North Pakistan (Taxila)(See the clip on Tiktok and Twitter). Noonan mentioned additional sources too, like from Fida Husnain (a known liar).
In 2026 (Jul), Ibrahim Noonan commented and alleged that Paul introduced polytheism into Christianity, Noonan then admitted that while Eisa (as) was alive, Paul was spreading his brand of Christianity. Noonan kept saying it was a different Christianity, however, we don’t differ on that point. Noonan alleged that the message of Eisa (as) was already corrupted while Eisa (as) was still alive. Noonan alleged that Paul elevated Jesus’ (as) status, however, Noonan would not say to God. A few seconds later, Noonan admitted to it and said that Paul elevated Jesus to a “divine-essence” (an object of worship). In the 2nd video, Ibrahim Noonan and Knowledge is power allege that St. Thomas travelled to India during the life of Eisa (as) and began spreading false Christianity therein. Noonan even alleged that St. Thomas met Jesus (as) in India. Noonan then alleged that St. Thomas was the brother of Jesus (as) was a Jew. Noonan wouldn’t accept that St. Thomas was a Christian, in fact, Noonan alleged that Eisa (as) was also a Jew. Noonan then calls St. Thomas a Jewish follower of Jesus (as). Noonan alleges that Peter, James and Thomas all rejected the teachings of Paul. Noonan alleges that he accidentally said that Thomas rejected Paul’s message. At this point, Noonan had accepted that Christians were in India and Eisa (as) was alive in Kashmir, India and this contradicts 5:116 of the Quran (5:117 in the Kadiani Koran). @Docf61 points out how Ahmadi’s believe that St. Thomas was already spreading the false teachings of Paul. @Docf61 points out how per Noonan, St. Thomas knew about the religion of Paul and rejected it, thus, he met Paul. At the end, Noonan says that maybe all the apostles didn’t reject Paul. @Docf61 points out how Noonan knows that the apostles met Paul and got caught since he couldn’t lie about it. Ahmadi’s even use the ‘Acts of Thomas” as they try to prove that Thomas came to India. In this video, you can see the Ahmadi mullah Ibrahim Noonan arguing that St. Thomas claims to have met Jesus in India 1900+ years ago.
In 2026 (Jul), Ansar Raza streamed on his own channel and quoted 5:116 (5:117 in the Kadiani Koran) and the recent debate between Sheikh Asrar Rashid vs. Maulvi Razi and alleged that Paul didn’t lead Christians astray. Ansar Raza argued that Paul didn’t create Christianity (13:19 time stamp), Ansar Raza argued that Paul started preaching to other than “Bani Israel”. Ansar Raza alleges that the brother of Eisa (as)(James aka Yaqub) confronted Paul about preaching to other than “Bani Israel”. Ansar Raza alleges that Paul didn’t lead “Bani Israel” astray, instead, Paul led “non-Bani-Israel” people astray. Ansar Raza alleges that Paul only told them one thing, i.e., that Jesus (as) died on the cross for the sins of humans on Earth. Ansar Raza also blamed the council of Nicea for leading Christians astray, however, this is all in contradiction to what MGA argued (See RK, V-19, p. 65)(See also, “Kishti-e-Nuh, online English edition, page 105), that it was Paul the Apostle who introduced the false belief of the Trinity into Christianity. At 16:28, Ansar Raza concluded that the majority of the beliefs of Christianity were not invented by Paul.
The ROR of July-1916 reports that Mufti Muhammad Sadiq visited Madras (also called Malabar and Chennai), and also visited the alleged Tomb of Saint Thomas. He then argued that this was in-fact a 1900 year old tomb, just like the Yuz Asaf tomb. Again, in 1916, via the ROR of Nov, an Ahmadi missionary, Hafiz Maulvi Ghulam Muhammad (B.A.) claimed that it wasn’t just Jesus who travelled to India, nay, he claimed that even St. Thomas had travelled to India and died. However, he didn’t tell the world that this was a lie from the Portuguese Empire. The Portuguese were the first Europeans in India and landed in coastal towns and setup their businesses. Ahmadi’s even use the ‘Acts of Thomas” as they try to prove that Thomas came to India. In this video, you can see the Ahmadi mullah Ibrahim Noonan arguing that St. Thomas claims to have met Jesus in India 1900+ years ago.
Continue reading “Ibrahim Noonan indirectly says that Christians went astray while Jesus was still alive in Kashmir, India” →
