Intro
In 2026 (Jun), @freepalestine20252025 (now as @khatim.info) engaged with @battaeclipse, just before the debate, @battaeclipse said in a boastful and rude way in Urdu that he was gonna have fun (muzza, 2:10 time stamp and 3:35) with @freepalestine20252025 (now working as @khatim.info), however, by the end of the discussion, he was crying about his English running out. @battaeclipse’s claim at the beginning was that the sahaba said that there will be a “new” prophet”. This was also his main argument in this discussion.
Firstly, @battaeclipse quoted the famous set of hadith wherein the death of Ibrahim (ra), the son of Muhammad (saw) is recorded and related by Anas bin Malik (Bukhari 1303). However, the matter of prophethood was not discussed in this hadith. @freepalestine20252025 (now as @khatim.info) then quoted Bukhari 6194, which is an extended version of the same hadith, however, the narrators are different, they are Ismail and Abi `Aufa. In this extended version Abi `Aufa, who is a sahaba, clearly said that the son of Muhammad (Saw) only died because there is NO prophet after Muhammad (saw). Thus proving that the sahaba didn’t believe that any NEW person would be granted prophethood.
At one point, @battaeclipse tried to divert the conversation from “is there a new prophet after Muhammad (Saw), to what is the meaning of “La Nabiya Badi”.
At another point, @battaeclipse tried to divert the conversation and forced @freepalestine20252025 (now as @khatim.info) to discuss if some sahaba will go to Hell or not.
Half way through the discussion, a new Ahmadi came on (with better English, cough cough), and said that Ahmadi’s don’t have to follow the sahaba, and in Ahmadiyya theology, some of the sahaba will go to Hell.
@freepalestine20252025 (now as @khatim.info) argued that per 9:100 of the Quran (9:101 in the Kadiani Koran), he follows the Sahaba in their goodness.
Close to the end, @battaeclipse was asking for a Fatwa.
Continue reading “Ahmadi’s throw the sahaba behind their back, get washed by @freepalestine (Jun-2026)” →