ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

Intro
MGA loved to quote 35:43 as he argued that Allah doesn’t change his ways or contradict himself. However, Allah is talking about punishing evil people after a Messenger (Rasul) has been sent to them, and it is Allah’s sunnah to punish them. However, in the case of Yunus (as), Allah granted an exemption.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s

The people of Yunus (as) were given a reprieve from punishment from Allah, they are an exception to the rule of repentance – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags

#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #ahmadianswers #ahmadiyyamuslimcommunity #ahmadiyya_creatives #ahmadiyyatthetrueislam #ahmadiyyatzindabad #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiyyamuslim #mirzaghulamahmad #qadiani #qadianism

Intro
Ahmadi’s will argue for hours and hours and claim that Allah is everywhere. They argue that Allah is in the Heavens (Jannah and Samaa Wattay) and the Earth (ardh) simultaneously. They got this from MGA, since they deny 4:158 and thus were forced to say that Allah is eveywhere, since 4:158 proves that Allah took Eisa (as) body and soul towards himself aka the Heavens (Jannah and Samaa Wattay).

Ironically, MGA even said Allah was in the the Heavens (Jannah and Samaa Wattay). In Tiryaqul-Qulub, Ruhani Khaza’in, vol. 15, page 499, MGA clearly claims that Allah is in the “Asmaan” (heavens). There are 4 additional references, See RK-3:180, RK-5:409, RK-15:499 and RK-22:154.

Continue reading “Mirza Ghulam Ahmad said Allah was in the sky (asmaan)” →

Intro
Salaam Bhatti is teaching an 8-week masterclass on how to research and write effective letters to the editor addressing allegations concerning Islam, as well as techniques aimed at enhancing writing proficiency for social media. Starting on December 4, 2023, join the Majlis Ansar Sultan-ul-Qalam (The Muslim Writers Guild), Salaam Bhatti is the chairman.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s

Salaam Bhatti (@salaam) / X (twitter.com)

Home | Muslim Writers Guild of America

https://twitter.com/muslim_writers?lang=en

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags

#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #ahmadianswers #ahmadiyyamuslimcommunity #ahmadiyya_creatives #ahmadiyyatthetrueislam #ahmadiyyatzindabad #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiyyamuslim #mirzaghulamahmad #qadiani #qadianism

Intro
When Mufti Muhammad Sadiq arrived in the USA (Philadelphia) he was held at the immigration authorities sent a cable to India to confirm his identity. They also seem to have had issues with his religious beliefs in terms of polygamy. Mufti Muhammad Sadiq told the U.S. government that he was not a polygamist and confessed to having a wife and kids in India (see the Evening Public Ledger, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Feb 20, 1920). The Immigration Act of 1870 understood polygamy as a commandment of Islam, thus not allowing Muslims into America. Mufti Sadiq, by appealing against the deportation orders of the immigration authorities and by presenting his case before the American federal Government. In fact, in the July-1921 edition of the Moslem Sunrise, Mufti Muhammad Sadiq wrote an entire article against Polygamy. He even said that if a Muslim practices polygamy in the USA he is committing a sin against his own religion (islam). He goes on to say Polygamy is a permission in Islam, not a commandment.

However, in Dec of 1922, he secretly and illegally married Edith V. Hoffman in what seems to be an islamic only Nikkah and not registered with the state of illinois or the City of Chicago. Edith V. Hoffman was a married woman.

In Feb of 1923, Mufti Muhammad Sadiq travelled to Buffalo and Edith V. Hoffman was with him, he gave a speech on Polygamy therein which was covered by the Buffalo Evening Times of Tuesday, Feb-13-1923 (See the scan in the below). Edith V. Hoffman was his secretary. Mufti Muhammad Sadiq lies about the islamic ideals on taking another wife. He says that a Muslim can take a new wife any time he likes. He forgets that the Quran strictly told a Muslim man that if he cannot do justice, he shouldn’t take a second or 3rd wife.

A baby girl (Noor Sadiq) was born to Mufti Sadiq and Hoffman in Aug of 1923 and in Philadelphia. The police were on to him in late Aug-1923, wherein he fled from Philadelphia and immediately left the country via Massachussets.

Evening Public Ledger, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Feb 20, 1920 say “I am not a polygamist myself, having only one wife, who is in India”.

Continue reading “Mufti Muhammad Sadiq told the U.S. Government that he wasn’t a polygamist, but 2 years later, he married a 2nd wife” →

Intro
The first ever mosque built in the USA was at 242 Victor Ave, Highland Park, Michigan. The construction work began in Jan of 1921 (See the Detroit Free Press, Tuesday, January 11, 1921). It was financed by Muhammad Karoub (spelled as Mohammet Karoub in the Detroit Free press), a rich Arab (Syrian) Real Estate mogul. Karoub employed architect Theodore Degenhardt to design the mosque. Sheikh Hassan Karoub has approved the design work and his brother Muhammad Karoub was paying 45,000 to buy the property. The Detroit Free Press alleges that there are 15,000 Muslims living in the immediate area and this mosque would serve there needs. These same Muslims hadn’t celebrated Eid or Juma at any mosque since they arrived in the USA. A few years after opening, the mosque was empty, Muslims were upset that Mufti Muhammad Sadiq was getting funding from Karoub and spreading his Kufr beliefs (See the Detroit Free Press, 24 Sep, 1922, p. 75). The city of Highland Park also imposed taxes and thus forcibly shut the mosque down.

The Mosque opened in June of 1921, it was simply called “The Moslem Mosque” and was financed by Muhammad Karoub (spelled as Mohammet Karoub in the Detroit Free press), a rich Arab Real Estate mogul. The Detroit Free Press of June 5th, 1921 alleges that there are 16,000 Muslims working in Detroit and Highland Park (mostly employed at Highland Park Ford Plant). Just a few years earlier, Muhammad Karoub moved to Highland Park and started as a factor worker for at the Highland Park Ford Plant. He seems to have made some amazing financial decisions and now was giving back to his community in the form of a mosque.

Mufti Muhammad Sadiq was in Chicago in May of 1921, however he came back to Detroit in June of 1921 and agreed to lead the Eid prayer for the first ever Eid Sermon and congregation in the USA. Hassan Karoub would give the sermon and Khaleel Bizzy would also help out as needed. However, Mufti Muhammad Sadiq was the highest ranking imam.

After the Eid prayers and etc., Mufti Muhammad Sadiq, Hassan Karoub and Khaleel Bizzy were going to be part of the parade. In fact, they would lead the parade, and Mufti Muhammad Sadiq would wear a green turban to signify the highest rank of the imam’s (a sheikh) and Hassan Karoub and Khaleel Bizzy would wear white turbans (imam’s) signifying a lower rank (the Detroit Free Press of June 5th, 1921). They would be followed by the Arabian American Association and the Muhammadan (spelled as Mohammedan) Young Men’s Association. The parade started from 72 Victor Ave and was owned by Muhammad Karoub himself and named Karoub Building.

After the parade and etc., Mufti Muhammad Sadiq seems to have got money from Muhammad Karoub and thus launched the famous “Moslem Sunrise” newspaper of July, 1921, (See the Detroit Free Press, 24 Sep, 1922, p. 75). Karoub is mentioned in this edition, his name is also spelled as Karroub (see 21). He even allowed Muftree Muhammad Sadiq to live in on his buildings on Victor Ave, Karoub House. Karoub’s photo appears in the Oct-1921 edition of the Moslem Sunrise. His brother’s photo is also given, the story of his brothers is also given, also that they are Syrian.

By 1922 the mosque lost its membership altogether, as a result of Mufti Muhammad Sadiq and his deviant beliefs. The congregation was split, confused and stopped attending altogether (See the Rutledge Daily Herald, Aug-28-1922). The other imam’s were Hassan Karoub (Sunni imam)(Muhammad Karoub’s brother, spelled as Hussien Karoub and Kaelil Bizzy) and Khaleel Bizzy (Shia imam).

The same newspaper (See the Rutledge Daily Herald, Aug-28-1922) tells us that the City of Highland Park added this property on the tax rolls and demanded 55,000. It seems that the city of Highland Park refused to allow this to be a mosque.

Continue reading “Who is Muhammad Karoub?” →

Intro
Joseph Erazium was a Christian Armenian immigrant and owner of a restaurant in Philadelphia. He is famous in Ahmadiyya history because his wife (Edith V. Hoffman) was stolen by Mufti Muhammad Sadiq and married her in 1922.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s

Who is Edith V. Hoffman aka Edith Sadiq aka Edith Erazium aka Edith Sadiq Erazium – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

Mufti Muhammad Sadiq had sex with another man’s wife from 1921 to 1923-then fled the country – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags

#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #ahmadianswers #ahmadiyyamuslimcommunity #ahmadiyya_creatives #ahmadiyyatthetrueislam #ahmadiyyatzindabad #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiyyamuslim #mirzaghulamahmad #qadiani #qadianism

Intro
The first ever mosque built in the USA was at 242 Victor Ave, Highland Park, Michigan. The construction work began in Jan of 1921 (See the Detroit Free Press, Tuesday, January 11, 1921). It was financed by Muhammad Karoub (spelled as Mohammet Karoub in the Detroit Free press), a rich Arab Real Estate mogul. Karoub employed architect Theodore Degenhardt to design the mosque. Sheikh Hassan Karoub has approved the design work and his brother Muhammad Karoub was paying 45,000 to buy the property. The Detroit Free Press alleges that there are 15,000 Muslims living in the immediate area and this mosque would serve there needs. These same Muslims hadn’t celebrated Eid or Juma at any mosque since they arrived in the USA. A few years after opening, the mosque was empty, Muslims were upset that Mufti Muhammad Sadiq was getting funding from Karoub and spreading his Kufr beliefs. The city of Highland Park also imposed taxes and thus forcibly shut the mosque down.

The Mosque opened in June of 1921, it was simply called “The Moslem Mosque” and was financed by Muhammad Karoub (spelled as Mohammet Karoub in the Detroit Free press), a rich Arab Real Estate mogul. The Detroit Free Press of June 5th, 1921 alleges that there are 16,000 Muslims working in Detroit and Highland Park (mostly employed at Highland Park Ford Plant). Just a few years earlier, Muhammad Karoub moved to Highland Park and started as a factor worker for at the Highland Park Ford Plant. He seems to have made some amazing financial decisions and now was giving back to his community in the form of a mosque.

Mufti Muhammad Sadiq was in Chicago in May of 1921, however he came back to Detroit in June of 1921 and agreed to lead the Eid prayer for the first ever Eid Sermon and congregation in the USA. Hassan Karoub would give the sermon and Khaleel Bizzy would

After the Eid prayers and etc., Mufti Muhammad Sadiq, Hassan Karoub and Khaleel Bizzy were going to be part of the parade. In fact, they would lead the parade, and Mufti Muhammad Sadiq would wear a green turban to signify the highest rank of the imam’s (a sheikh) and Hassan Karoub and Khaleel Bizzy would wear white turbans (imam’s) signifying a lower rank (the Detroit Free Press of June 5th, 1921). They would be followed by the Arabian American Association and the Muhammadan (spelled as Mohammedan) Young Men’s Association. The parade started from 72 Victor Ave and was owned by Muhammad Karoub himself and named Karoub Building.

After the parade and etc., Mufti Muhammad Sadiq seems to have got money from Muhammad Karoub and thus launched the famous “Moslem Sunrise” newspaper of July, 1921, from the

By 1922 the mosque lost its membership altogether, as a result of Mufti Muhammad Sadiq and his deviant beliefs. The congregation was split, confused and stopped attending altogether (See the Rutledge Daily Herald, Aug-28-1922). The other imam’s were Hassan Karoub (Sunni imam)(Muhammad Karoub’s brother, spelled as Hussien Karoub and Kaelil Bizzy) and Khaleel Bizzy (Shia imam).

The same newspaper (See the Rutledge Daily Herald, Aug-28-1922) tells us that the City of Highland Park added this property on the tax rolls and demanded 55,000. It seems that the city of Highland Park refused to allow this to be a mosque.

The mosque was subject to several issues. The Detroit Free Press reported in 1924 that the constant traffic and noise in the area made the location unsuitable for a mosque. The lack of sufficient funding may have also been a problem, and people had varying visions for how it should have been built.^[4] Due to the issues, Karoub sold the mosque to Highland Park in 1926.^[1][5]

As of 2016, the land is currently being used by the John E. Green Company, a mechanical contractor.^[1]

Continue reading “The first ever Mosque built in the USA” →

Intro
Charles Frances Seivwright was born on 21 May 1862 to Josephine Cornelia Lahon and Marcus Sievwright and in Fitzroy, Victoria, Australia. He died on 11 Nov 1934 at the age of 72.  

Continue reading “Who is Charles F. Sievwright and his sexual connections to Qadian and brown women?” →

Intro
Edith V. Hoffman seems to have been a woman from Altoona, Pennsylvania. Her parents seem to have been German immigrants to the USA. During WW-1 she worked for the Red Cross and even served in Turkey (1914–1920, roughly). During her service, she met a man named Joseph Erazium, who was a Christian Armenian, they seem to have fell in love with each other.

A few years later (1921), the two met up in New Orleans and seem to have gotten married and then moved to Philadelphia, where Joseph Erazium lived and owned a restaurant. In late 1921 (allegedly a few days after they seperated), Edith Erazium disappeared and allegedly returned to her parents home in Altoona. However, her husband Joseph Erazium couldn’t find her, and he kept looking earnestly.

In the Moslem Sunrise of Jan-1923, Mrs. Edith Virginie Hoffman is listed as a married woman (See Page 169)(She is also quoted on page 177). In Feb of 1923 she was working as Dr. Mufti Sadiq’s secretary as reported by the Buffalo Times of Feb-13-1923 (see the scans in the below). She was named Sadiqa Sadiq (see page 190,196, 214) and listed as a Registered Nurse (R.N.) in the Moslem Sunrise of Apr-July-1923, thus indicated indirectly that she had married Mufti Muhammad Sadiq.

In Aug. of 1923, her name popped up in the in The Philadelphia Inquirer of Wednesday, Aug-22-1923 and it stated that Edith V. Hoffman was married to Dr. Mufti Sadiq. The newspaper even gave the address (3940 Walnut St) where she and her husband Dr. Mufti Sadiq and their 2-week old daughter could be found. They had came to Philadephia from Chicago (most likely to escape the shame). In roughly Aug-8-1923, Mufti Sadiq’s alleged wife Edith Hoffman gave birth to their daughter and named her Noor (Arabic for light). This means that Edith Hoffman got pregnant by Mufti Sadiq in Dec. of 1922 in Chicago (the same month that she got married). This daughter (Noor) was the first ever Ahmadi born in the USA.

Joseph Erazium read the newspaper and immediately went to 3940 Walnut St (a boarding house) and confronted Dr. Mufti Sadiq and Edith Hoffman. Erazium reminded Edith Hoffman that she was still married to him and asked to see her marriage certificate to Dr. Mufti Sadiq, Edith waffled and said it was not available. Erazium immediately went to get his lawyer, however, when he returned to 3940 Walnut St, Dr. Mufti Sadiq and Edith Hoffman (and their baby) were long gone. Erazium spent the whole night searching for them in hotels and etc. and found nothing.

The next day, he went to the local court (Central Station) and filed a case against Edith V. Hoffman for Bigamy and vs. Dr. Mufti Sadiq for stealing his wife. The case was filed and arrest warrants were issued for both Dr. Mufti Sadiq and Edith V. Hoffman by Magistrate Renshaw, he also wanted to investigate the religious activities of Dr. Mufti Sadiq. The Philadelphia Inquirer of Friday, Aug-24, 1923 reports that a case was filed and Edith Hoffman was taken in as a prisoner. Dr. Mufti Sadiq totally disappeared from Philadelphia. The police were actively looking for him. In the Philadelphia Inquirer of Friday, Aug-31-1923, it is reported that Edith Hoffman was arraigned and charged with eloping with Dr. Mufti Sadiq whilst still married to Joseph Erazium. Edith V. Hoffman claims that a lawyer in Chicago told her that she was legally  divorced and thus, she married Dr. Mufti Sadiq. Edith V. Hoffman admitted to marrying Erazium in 1921 and says that she left him a few days later and never lived with him ever again. She claims to have married Mufti Muhammad Sadiq in Dec-1922 with islamic rites. On Sep-1-1923 and via the Atlantic City Daily Press, Mufti Muhammad Sadiq was on his way out of America and was in Springfield, Massachussets. He seems to have immediately fled the country. Ahmadiyya sources also agree that he left the USA in Sep-1923 and never returned. His pseudo-wife and child were left.

Her name appears in the Moslem Sunrise of Oct-1923 as Sadiqa Sadiq and she is alleged to have donated $10 to the Berlin Mosque Fund. The name Sadiqah appeared in the Moslem Sunrise of Jan-1924 under an essay on Islam.

Continue reading “Who is Edith V. Hoffman aka Edith Sadiq aka Edith Erazium aka Edith Sadiq Erazium” →