Intro
In 1881, Abdullah Athim published his famous book, “Andrun-e-Bible” (Inner Nature of the Bible). Ahmadiyya sources allege that he called Muhammad (Saw) as Dajjal in this book. However, they have never given the page number so we can double check. Additionally, and ironically, if Abdullah Athim did write this book in 1881, and did in-fact call Muhammad (Saw) as Dajjal, then why did MGA even have a written debate with him? On social media, Ahmadi’s tell us that they don’t sit with people who mock Muhammad (Saw) and etc. and Ahmadi’s argue that its ok to cuss at people like this and call them “Children of Prostitutes” (Zurayatal Baghaya). However, in 1893, 12 years later, we have a case here wherein MGA had a 15-day debate with a man (Athim) who had cursed and mocked Muhammad (saw).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
1893
The Holy War (alislam.org)
Allegedly, during MGA’s 15-day written debate with Abdullah Athim, MGA mentions Andrunah Bible, he alleges that in this book, Athim called Muhammad (saw) as Dajjal and this was why MGA told him that he would die in 15 months.
______________________________________________________________________________________________
1902
In Ijaz-e-Ahmadi (see page 4), MGA mentions Andrunah Bible, he alleges that in this book, Athim called Muhammad (saw) as Dajjal and this was why MGA told him that he would die in 15 months.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
1906-1907
In Haqiqatul Wahy, MGA mentions Andruna-e-Bible twice, he alleges that in this book, Athim called Muhammad (saw) as Dajjal and this was why MGA told him that he would die in 15 months.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
1909
Nazulul Masih, Ruhani Khazain Vol 18. Pp 541-545
AhmadiAnswers | Abdullah Atham, A Christian Fraud
“In your book Adruna-e-Bible, you have called our Holy Prophetsaw Dajjal, whereas I belive him to be a true messenger, and I firmly believe Islam to be from God. Now this is something that will be decided by heaven. The heavenly decree is that whichever of us is false in his statement and unjustly declares the true messenger to be a liar and dajjal, and whichever of us is an enemy of the truth, shall be cast in hawia [hell] within fitfteen months from today, in the lifetime of the truthful one; unless he turns to the true i.e desists from calling the righteous and true Prophet saw Dajjal and refrains from impertinence and abuse. I said this because the mere denial of a religion does not merit punishment in this world, it is audacious, impertinent and insolent vilification that makes one deserve punishment. Thus when Atham was apprised of this prophecy in this gathering of more than seventy people, he blanched visibly, his face turned pale, and his hands started to tremble. He immediately took his tongue out of his mouth, touched his ears with both hands, and began to shake his head and hands just like frightened culprit who vehemently denies any wrongdoing, repents and shows great humility. With a quivering tongue, he kept saying, I repent! I repent! I am not guilty of any disrespect or blasphemy; and I have never called the Holy Prophet saw Dajjal. All the while he was trembling and this spectacle was not only be held by Muslims but his humble attitude was also witnessed by a large number of Christians. His denial seemed to signify that his statement in his book Andruna-e-Bible was not meant as an insult. In any case, he ended up retracting the word Dajjal before this gathering of about seventy people, and it was this one word that had occasioned this prophecy. He escaped death within a period of fifteen months, because he had recanted that blasphemous word on which the prophecy depended and God would surely never forget the condition that he himself had attached….”
______________________________________________________________________________________________
1948
Life of Ahmad (alislam.org)
Dard alleges that in another book, Al-Jawahirul Quran (Chashma’-e-Nur Press, Amritsar,
1884, p. 108) Athim had written that the description of the First Woe given
in Revelation 9:2,3,10,11 applied, word for word, exactly to Muhammad (saw).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s
The “Zarrayatul baghaya” insult by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad was meant for Muslims – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad said it’s OK to cuss at people who mock Muhammad (saw) – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad had 5 written debates, NO ORAL Debates – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #ahmadianswers #ahmadiyyamuslimcommunity #ahmadiyya_creatives #ahmadiyyatthetrueislam #ahmadiyyatzindabad #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiyyamuslim #mirzaghulamahmad #qadiani #qadianism
1 Pingback