Intro
Lots of Ahmadis don’t understand this simple concept. They are taught to question the idea that if Esa (as) is to phsyically return to Earth, then in-fact, Esa (as) is the last prophet and not Muhammad (saw). However, as the facts will prove, Muhammad (Saw) is the last prophet in terms of the bloodline of prophets which ended upon the death of Muhammad (saw).
A few years later, Muhammad (Saw) has a son
Muhammad (saw) married an egyptian woman (roughly 8, A.H.) and had a son named Ibrahim (ra). This birth seemed to have contradicted 33:40, however, the son died shortly thereafter, and many hadith were recorded with the insinuation that Ibrahim (ra) may have died so as to confirm that Muhammad (saw) was in fact the Final prophet.
Does Esa’s (as) return contradict 33:40?
MGA had heard this argument, he knew from his days in Sialkot. Christians and Hindus may have pointed this contradiction, nonetheless, MGA remembered it and used it against the ulema as for many years. Nonetheless, Esa (as)’s return has no bearing on Muhammad (saw) being the final prophet, since Esa (As) was born before Muhammad (saw).
Conclusions
Ahmadis are brainwashed to think a certain way, to question many things about Islam and thats the psychology here. I just wanted to type this up as a matter of fact.
1 Pingback