Just yesterday, a Qadiani-Ahmadi named Ayman Odeh (not to be confused with the Ahmadi poliltician in Haifa with the same name, Aymen Odeh) gave his research on Mirza Ghulam Ahmad and how he learned arabic via the Ahmadi Answers youtube channel, watch my response video on this herein. We have catalogued how some people from the Odeh family have famously left Ahmadiyya herein. Most of the Odeh family is from Kababir, Haifa, Israel (read this thesis herein). Nevertheless, he started on MGA and arabic and quickly revealed that he starts with the bias that MGA is never incorrect. This is the psychology of the Ahmadi. He then says that he found MGA’s arabic in many arabic grammatical books. Which arabic grammatical books? He doesn’t tell us. He also doesn’t give his qualifications either. He never says the word Qiraat, instead he kept saying “arabic languages”, Razi Ullah Noman had to put it into his mouth. He mentions some type of arabic grammar book. He accused Muslims of behaving like the opponents of the Quran. This is a classic Qadiani-Ahmadi argument tactic, to attack Muslims, instead of trying to explain Ahmadiyya. He says that the same “alleged” mistakes that MGA made also occur in the quran (see my tik tok herein). He brings up a phrase, “alam tara ila” (see 25:45, 58:3 of the quran). However, we don’t know who raised this specific objection. Aymen Odeh claims that this occurs in the quran 15 times. He brings up another mistake in a revelation of MGA, “akana linasay ajaboon”, however, he doesn’t give a verse number. The proper Quranic verse should be “akana linasay ajaban”. He claims to have found a qiraat which supports this error of MGA. He then quotes the qiraat of Ibn Masud. He then accuses Sahih Bukhari of having mistakes in it and the qiraat and all other arabic manuscripts. This is where he tells the world that if MGA made mistakes in arabic, then so did everyone else, which is the classic ahmadiyya deflection (see the tik tok herein). He then accuses Imam Shafi of making grammatical mistakes. He is bold enough to claim that MGA was taught arabic by his GOD and thus brought out new phraseology. He keeps saying that he doesn’t need to know every single detail about MGA, nor have any ahmadi’s went that deep, nor do they care to. He then claims to have written a book wherein all of this can be found, however, its an unpublished summary.
Razi then brings up a quotation from Mirza Masroor Ahmad wherein he confirms that Ahmadi-arab scholars (Hani Tahir) and brought up all the errors of MGA and some others had suggested that Mirza Masroor Ahmad order the editing of them. Ironically, a few days ago, the Khalifa of Islam admitted to not being able to pronounce the quran properly.
Furthermore, MGA claimed that all of his arabic books are like revelation.
The other Aymen Odeh from Kababir
Ayman Odeh (on twitter as @AyOdeh)(born 1 January 1975) identifies as an Israeli Arab lawyer and politician. He was raised in Haifa, within the Kababir neighbourhood. His father was a construction worker. Odeh is married to Nardine Aseli, a gynecologist, whom he met at the wake for her 17-year-old brother who was killed in 2000 at the start of the Second Intifada.They have three children.
Although his family was Qadiani-Ahmadi, Odeh’s parents sent him to a Christian school where he was the only Ahmadi student, proudly noting that he got an A in New Testament studies on his high school final exams. He now describes himself as having transcended the confines of religion and ethnicity. He studied law at the University of Craiova in Romania from 1993 to 1997. During his law studies in Romania, he took part in pro-Palestinian rallies, learned Romanian, and read the memoirs of various political thinkers and revolutionaries. He earned a Bachelor of Laws degree from the University of Craiova and in 2001 was certified to practice law in Israel, though he is not a member of the Israel Bar Association.
Odeh joined Hadash, and represented it on Haifa City Council between 1998 and 2005, before becoming the party’s secretary-general in 2006. He was placed 75th on the party’s list for the 2009 elections, in which Hadash won four seats. He won sixth place on the party’s list for the 2013 Knesset elections, but failed to enter the Knesset, as the party again won four seats.
Following the announcement that Hadash leader Mohammed Barakeh was resigning prior to the 2015 elections, Odeh was elected as the party’s new leader. In the buildup to the 2015 elections, Hadash joined the Joint List, an alliance of the main Arab parties. Odeh was placed at the head of the Joint List’s electoral list. Analysts credited the charismatic Odeh for giving the Arab political union a more moderate, pragmatic face. Odeh was elected to the 20th Knesset, along with 12 other candidates from the Joint List.
In an interview with The Times of Israel, Odeh discussed the Joint List’s social agenda, including a 10-year plan to tackle issues pertinent to the Arab sector, such as employment of women, rehabilitation of failing regional councils, recognition of unrecognized Bedouin communities in the Negev, public transportation in Arab towns, and eradication of violence. He also said he supported the right of the Jewish people to self-determination in Israel, adding that a Palestinian state should fulfill the same goals for Arab Palestinians.
Odeh’s campaign for the March 2015 elections had a “breakthrough moment” when, in a televised debate of candidates, Avigdor Lieberman, Israel’s foreign minister, called Odeh a “Palestinian citizen” and said Odeh was not welcome in Israel. Odeh replied, “I am very welcome in my homeland. I am part of the nature, the surroundings, the landscape”, contrasting his birth in Israel with Lieberman’s immigration from the former Soviet Union. Odeh is now viewed as a potential power broker given that Arab parties appear to be uniting to meet the government’s requirement that parties meet a minimum threshold of votes to secure a place in the Knesset. Odeh has a style that contrasts with that of MK Haneen Zoabi, who is more confrontational. Odeh voices his willingness to work with Jewish partners, and he often quotes Martin Luther King Jr.
In the 2020 election, Odeh and the Joint List recommended Benny Gantz for prime minister.
Award and recognition
- Listed as top 100 leading global thinkers by Foreign Policy magazine
- Listed as top 100 influential by TheMarker magazine for the year 2016, and was listed in the 9th place
- Listed as top 100 influential by TheMarker magazine for the year 2017
Views and opinions
Odeh says his service on Haifa City Council made it clear to him that Arabs and Jews must work together. He describes Haifa as “the most liberal multicultural yet homogenous city in Israel”.
Odeh has also expressed strong support for increasing recognition of Mizrahi culture and Arab Jewish history in official Israeli and Palestinian discourses; in a widely cited speech to the Knesset plenum in July 2015, MK Odeh argued that the State of Israel has systematically discriminated against and suppressed the culture of Jews who immigrated to Israel from Arab and Muslim lands (who make up the majority of the Israeli population) in order to feed the idea of a natural separation between Jews and Arabs. He also argued that the large role played by Jews in forming historical and modern Arab culture (including famous Jews such as Rabbi David Buzaglo, who wrote Jewish religious poetry primarily in Arabic, and famous Jews who were popular in the Arab world in the mid-20th century, such as Leila Mourad), has been forgotten by Jews and Arabs alike due to the ideological elements of the Arab–Israeli conflict, and the desire by Israel’s elite to portray a Western image of Jews and of the country. Odeh called upon Jewish and Arab members of the Knesset alike to support a new Knesset committee (which he had joined as a member) lobbying for the re-emphasizing of the culture of Jews from Arab and Muslim lands. In that speech, Odeh summarized his position thus: “The culture of the Jews of Arab and Islamic countries is a shared Jewish and Arab culture. Because of this, the state has fought [against] it, and yet because of this [same reason], we must fight to strengthen it.”
Odeh says, “We represent those who are invisible in this country, and we give them a voice. We also bring a message of hope to all people, not just to the Arabs, but to the Jews, too”.
In October 2015, Odeh gave support to the “unarmed Palestinian struggle”. However, when asked about “throwing rocks, … firebombs, and shooting at cars”, Odeh responded that regarding throwing rocks, he supported the first intifada.
In February 2016, Odeh considered resigning from the Knesset to show his protest against a controversial MK suspension bill.
Shin Bet interrogations
Israel’s internal intelligence agency, the Shin Bet, has interrogated Odeh many times in the past. He said in an interview to The New Yorker: “I was called three more times by the Shin Bet. They never hit me. But they succeeded in two things. I isolated myself from my friends—I became much more introverted. And I had the sense the Shin Bet was watching me no matter where I went. When I went to the bus station, and I saw some guy in sunglasses, I just assumed he was Shin Bet.”
A right-wing activist was arrested in February 2016 for making death threats against Odeh.
Umm al-Hiran incident
On 18 January 2017, Odeh was allegedly shot by a sponge-tipped bullet in the forehead by Israel Police as he protested against the demolition of homes in the Bedouin village of Umm al-Hiran. The police initially claimed that he was hit by stones thrown by other protestors. It later backtracked, claiming both that it had never stated that Odeh was hit by stones and that it didn’t know what caused Odeh’s head injury.
The British Forensic Architecture, led by Eyal Weizman of Goldsmiths, University of London, which analyzed video evidence of the incident strongly suspected that Odeh had been hit by a sponge-tipped bullet because 47 seconds of video had been redacted – precisely the time during which Odeh was injured.
Links and Related Essay’s
Maulvi Sher Ali told the world that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad would send his Arabic writings to Noorudin and Ahsan Amrohi for editing
“Ahmadiyya, beliefs and experiences” (2000) by Hassan Bin Mahmood Odeh–An Ex-Ahmadi from Kababir, Haifa, Israel
Kababir: an Ahmadiyya community in Israel by Ray Register (1970)–Hartford Seminary Foundation–Thesis/dissertation
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #ahmadianswers #ahmadiyyamuslimcommunity #ahmadiyya_creatives #ahmadiyyatthetrueislam #ahmadiyyatzindabad #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiyyamuslim #mirzaghulamahmad #qadiani #qadianism