ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

Intro
Ahmadi’s are taught to lie about their beliefs all the time. Thus, Maulvi Razi and others constantly hide their true beliefs. In 1902, via Noah’s Ark (see page 30, online english edition), MGA and his team of writers wrote that Maryam got married while she was 6-7 months pregnant with Eisa (as)(See Chashma-Masihi, online english edition, page 28, 1906). MGA and his team were authenticating Luke 1:27 and Matthew 13:55-56.

Remember, in 1898, MGA was accusing Maryam of meeting up with Joseph the carpenter even before her Nikkah (astagfarullah)(See roohani khazyian 14 -page 300, ayam alsulah, see in the below). In this same book, MGA said that the pathan people of Pakistan/Afghanistan and Jews are similar, and Maryam met with Joseph before they married each other (astagfarullah). MGA says the same in Mawahibur-Rahman (1903, see page 66). Also in 1902, MGA quoted 21:91 (21:92 in the Qadiani Quran) of the Quran and claimed that Maryam was called a married woman (Ahsanat). MGA then quoted 4:24, specifically the phrase “wa mushanatoo” and gave it as a parallel.

It all starts at 24:53, Bro Imtiaz tells Razi that MGA alleged that Maryam had a nikkah with Joseph while she was 5 months pregnant (reference unknown)(and at 40:27, Imtiaz calls it a big blasphemy). Razi agrees that MGA said this (27:27 time stamp). At 28:27 Razi tries to derail the stream. At 42:05, Bro Imran re-iterates the question to Razi. At 51:37, Bro Imtiaz re-iterates and reminds Razi that he must answer as to why MGA revealed this new info about Maryam? Was it to break to the cross? Razi mentioned how MGA called this (Maryam’s nikkah with Joseph) as a “historical error” in Islam (53:32)(astagfarullah)(See Malfuzat, Vol-3, page 175-176), which he (MGA) corrected (this ref is cut off and can’t be found in the older editions of Malfuzat).

At 56:40, Bro Imtiaz continues to re-iterate how MGA was using biblical narratives and ignoring the Quran. At 1:00:19, Razi quoted 21:91 of the Quran (And MGA, this ref is unknown)(and specifically the phrase “ahsanat”[guarded]) as he argued that Maryam must have been married to Joseph (since MGA said so), while she was 5 months pregnant with Eisa (as). Razi argued that at other places in the Quran, “ahsanat”[guarded]) was used to show a married woman, and thus, when Maryam was referred to in 21:92, she was already married. However, Razi was wrong, we find the phrase “wa mushanatoo” (and guarded) used 5 times in the Quran, see 4:24 for one example. Razi was trying to link “Ahsanat” to “Muh-sanaat”. Eventually, Razi conceded (1:01:55 time stamp to 1:03:15). Razi then quirms all the way to 1:07:00, Razi admits that the phrase “Muh-sanaat” includes married and non-married women and thus concedes the entire argument, however, the reference to MGA was never given. At 1:16:33, Razi says that some people in history have been born without a father, he also says that he hasn’t read enough on this topic.

At the 1:16:57, Bro Imtiaz brings up the fact that in Islam, only Eisa (as) was born without father, no one else. In terms of the “Hermaphrodite-theory”, Razi claims that he hasn’t done enough research (1:17:40 time stamp and 1:19:10), he calls himself unofficial when cornered. However, Razi disagrees and says others have also been born the same way as Eisa (as), but he doesn’t have any examples (see 1:20:50).

On 8-24-23, Razi tweeted about Maryam, and with Quranic proofs that she has both sexual reproductive organs (both systems). Mirza Tahir Ahmad went a step further in his assertions. He eventually asserted that Maryam (ra) was a hermaphrodite, watch this tik tok clip. This clip is from a question and answer session by Mirza Tahir Ahmad in the 1990’s. Mirza Tahir Ahmad also said that a woman from Africa was the first human. In 1998, Mirza Tahir Ahmad compared the birth of Eisa (as) to those of animals who had both genders (From June 14, 1998) 24:45 time stamp. He also argues that many females in the world can have children without a male touching them.

Interestingly, in 2022, A qadiani-Ahmadi named Dr. Jalil Ahmad Bhatti wrote an article wherein he accused Maryam of being a hermaphrodite. In 2023, I asked the West Africans about this and they had no idea. Even Maulvi Noonan admitted online that Maryam is a hermaphrodite. Maulvi Farhan Iqbal agrees that it is possible that Maryam was a hermaphrodite.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
1902
Malfuzat, Vol-3, page 175-176, 2022 edition
Placed in Oct-1-1902 by the Qadianis

Commentary
MGA said that Maryam had a nikkah with Joseph while she was pregnant. Razi even quoted 4:24 of the Quran as he argued that Maryam must have been married to Joseph (since MGA said so), while she was pregnant with Eisa (as). Razi was quoting the phrase “wa mushanatoo” (word was used 5 times in the Quran) in 4:24 and said that Maryam was also called “wa mushanatoo”, however, Razi was trying to link muh-sanaat to ahsanat. Eventually, Razi conceded. He did mention how MGA called this as a “historical error” in Islam (astagfarullah)(See Malfuzat, Vol-3, page 175-176).

Scan

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Mawahibur-Rahman (1903, see page 66)

“One of the doctrines we hold is that Jesus Christ and John the Baptist were both born miraculously . . . And the secret in creating Jesus and John in this manner was the manifestation of a great sign . . . And the first thing He [God] did to bring this about was the creation of Jesus without a father through the manifestation of Divine power only.” (Mawahib al-Rahman, pp. 70-72).

“And this is also a part of our belief that the birth of Jesus took place against the normal laws”…….

“Either we believe that Jesus was born on the decree of God, such is the way of Allah, He creates what He pleases, When He decrees a thing He says to it, ‘To be,’ and it is. Or, God forbid, his birth was illegitimate.” (Ruhani Khaza’in, v. 19, Introduction to the book Page 17).

^^^ These are quoted here.  See page 344.

Mawahibur-Rahman, Ruhani Khaza’in, vol 19, p. 295
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
1903
Nasim-e-Da‘wat, Ruhani Khaza’in, Vol. 19, pp. 381
https://www.youtube.com/live/v32Lm0-rLMM?si=QFuSdTdhD8wC6xE7

Translation
Mary was slandered/accused and this slander humiliated the wonder of the birth of Eisa (as). But in this slander, the Jews alone are not be to blamed, but Mary herself had made a huge mistake, which gave the Jews an opportunity to slander her, and that is when Mary saw the angel in her vision/dream, and when the angel announced the good news of the pregnancy, Maryam deliberately kept this vision a secret, and she never told anyone, because her mother and father had dedicated her to the temple (Baitul Maqdas), she would always stay and work at the temple, and she would not ever marry and will remain a virgin. And she had herself decided that she would not get a husband and would remain in Baitul Maqdas. After having this dream, she had this fear, that if she disclosed this secret, that an angel has given her the good news of a boy, people will think it is a ploy to get married. That’s why, she kept this vision/dream a secret. But that dream was true, she got pregnant at the same time. And Maryam was unaware of this pregnancy for some time. After the 5th month of the pregnancy had passed, then it became famous that Maryam was pregnant, and then Maryam told people about her dream, but at that time it was useless to say so. At the end, her elders (Jewish elders), in an attempt to hide her shame/guilt, they got her married to Joseph the Carpenter. This is how this prophecy was stained””. 

Scan
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s

Mirza Tahir Ahmad called Esa (as)’s mother a Hermaphrodite!!!! – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

Luke 1:27 – to a virgin pledged to be married to a man named J… (biblestudytools.com)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags

#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #ahmadianswers #ahmadiyyamuslimcommunity #ahmadiyya_creatives #ahmadiyyatthetrueislam #ahmadiyyatzindabad #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiyyamuslim #mirzaghulamahmad #qadiani #qadianism