Intro
In 1917 (Sep), the Lahori-Ahmadi leader, Maulvi Muhammad Ali’s book “Ahmad Mujtaba” was published, in which it is argued from the Quran, Hadith reports and the writings of the Promised Messiah that ‘Ahmad’ was the name of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (saw) and the prophecy referred to in the words ismu-hu Ahmad, “his name being Ahmad”, in the Quran (chapter 61, verse 6) referred to him. This book was written to refute Mirza Basheer ud Din Mahmud Ahmad’s wrong belief that this prophecy applied to Mirza Ghulam Ahmad. To counter this erroneous belief Maulana Muhammad Ali and other scholars of the community had already written many articles in Paigham Sulh, and the Maulana had invited Mirza Mahmud Ahmad several times to a decisive debate on the matter, but he did not accept the invitation (See “Mujahid-e-Kabir”).

In 1918 (Jan-6), Maulvi Muhammad Ali’s book, “The Ahmadiyya Movement, Part-4, the Split” was published. On page-10, Maulvi Muhammad Ali alleged that in 1914, as soon as he became the 2nd Khalifa, Mirza Basheer ud Din Mahmud Ahmad began arguing that MGA was a prophet and gave 61:6 (Ismuhu Ahmad) as evidence (See also page 27). On page 27 and 34, Maulvi Muhammad Ali quoted “Anwar-e-Khilafat”, which was the main speech of the 2nd Khalifa at the 1915 Jalsa at Qadian. On page 34, Maulvi Muhammad Ali accuses the Qadiani’s of calling “Ahmad” as simply as “attribute” of Muhammad (Saw)(See pages 27-76).

In 2026 (Nov), at 45:10, Bro Imtiaz plays a clip from the notorious Ahmadi Saleem Meer wherein Saleem Meer is arguing that the primary person for whom 61:6 was prophesied was Muhammad (Saw), however, MGA is also included because he is the zill (shadow). Saleem Meer then explained how the Qadiani position was that MGA was the primary person (haqiqi misdaq)(primary fulfillment, first fulfillment) for whom 61:6 was prophesied, and Muhammad (saw) could also be included (but not primarily). This is the Lahori-Ahmadi position.

______________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s

Who is Maulvi Muhammad Ali in the history of Ahmadiyya?

Click to access ahmadmujtabaa.pdf

The Qadiani-Ahmadi’s declared that MGA was “Ismuhu-Ahmad” in Quran 61:6, not Muhammad (Saw), then changed it later

https://www.muslim.org/books/m-kabir/mjk3-2.htm

“Ahmad Mujtaba” by Maulvi Muhammad Ali (Sep-1917) and vs. the Qadiani’s! – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

“Ahmad Mujtaba” by Maulvi Muhammad Ali (Sep-1917) and vs. the Qadiani’s!

The Paigham-e-Sulh magazine, background info and some important quotes – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

The Paigham-e-Sulh magazine, background info and some important quotes

Bro Imtiaz catches Musleh Shanboor lying about 61:6 (Ismuhu Ahmad) and Imam Suyuti – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

Bro Imtiaz catches Musleh Shanboor lying about 61:6 (Ismuhu Ahmad) and Imam Suyuti

Mirza Mahmud Ahmad retreats from his belief about the “coming Ahmad” prophecy

https://www.ahmadiyya.org/qadis/mm/pahmad.htm

Who is Saleem Meer? Aka Mindroaster Mir? – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

Who is Saleem Meer? Aka Mindroaster Mir?

The 1915 Jalsa at Qadian – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog

The 1915 Jalsa at Qadian

_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags

#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam