Intro
We have heard #ahmadis on social media claiming that the Muhammadi Begum prophecy failed just like Muhammad’s (saw) Hajj dream (nauzobilah). We wondered where these #ahmadi’s got this from, they must have heard it from Ahmadi mullahs during Jalsa’s and Ijtema’s. We have found the reference in MGA’s writings, its from Maktubat-e-Ahmad, Volume-2. This letter was written to Nawab Sardar Muhammad Ali Khan and MGA was discussing the failed prophecy of the death of Athim in 15 months. MGA was trying to create a parallel between his failed prophecy and an alleged failed prophecy by Muhammad (Saw) (nauzobillah). There is a note at the end of this letter, which seems to be from the editors, they claim that this letter has no date and no envelope. The editors claim that this letter is from September 1894. Maktubat-volume-2 was published after MGA died in 1912. Thus, we think it was added later.

The data
Maktubat-e-Ahmad, Maktub-12, pages 204-205, Volume-2
Summary

MGA says that Esa (as) had 70 companions leave him and in Tafsir Ibn Kathir writes that many companions of Muhammad (saw) left Islam after the failed Hajj and failed dream (nauzobillah) of Muhammad (saw). However, no one has ever found this in Tafsir ibn Kathir.

The scan work

Links and Related Essay’s
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Hudaybiyyah

Tags
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog