Intro
Watch my tik tok on this topic herein and instagram and youtube channel. Watch my 2nd tik tok too. In December of 1923, Seeratul Mahdi’s first edition was published. There was immediate backlash from the Muslims of India in terms of MGA’s lifestyle. In terms of pig fat, MGA had the habit of eating biscuits and cake’s which were most likely made with pig fat. Pig fat was used by the Europeans in many ways. In fact, the enfield rifle was required to be lubed by pig/beef capsules. This caused the famous rebellion of 1857. The story of MGA and his eating habits were given in extreme detail in Seeratul Mahdi.
Nevertheless, the Muslims of India immediately accused MGA of indiscriminately eating biscuits and other treats without caring to check if they had pig fat or not. This seems to have triggered the Ahmadiyya Movement to respond. Thus, in February of 1924, the assistant editor of the Al-Fazl magazine, Mehr Muhammad Khan found a fatwa from MGA from MGA’s diary and published it in the Al-Fazl of 22nd February, 1924. In this fabricated fatwa, MGA accused Muhammad (Saw) of eating cheese that was known to have pig fat in it. However, this is a lie, this never happened. Recently, Razi, the murrabi-in-training who owns the Ahmadi answers website has claimed that MGA was referring to Fathul Mu’in Sharhu Qur’atil Ain by Sheikh Zainul-Abidin Bin Abdul Aziz, under the heading Babus Salat. However, MGA never gave a reference, and this is not a hadith and it doesn’t mention pig fat at all.
It should be noted that the diary of MGA seems to have been a missing manuscript and thus totally doctored by the Khalifa at Qadian as the need arose to write a fatwa. Which is exactly what happened in this case.
The title of the essay in Al-Fazl is, “Hazrat Maseeh e Maud ka eik prana Maktub”, in english as “Hazrat Promised Messiah’s old letter”. In this fake letter, Ahmadi’s assert that MGA was claiming that if it is unknown if a food has pig fat in it, then, there is no sin in eating it and he accused Muhammad (saw) as such.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
My person experiences with pig fat
When I was a kid (1980’s), my dad found out that there was gelatin (pig fat) in marshmallows and thus our cereal has pig in it. My dad threw all the cereals out immediately. My dad didn’t know the fatwa of MGA.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
1889
MGA said it was ok to eat the meat of the “Naturees” (Sir Syed Ahmad Khan type of alleged Muslims).
1923
Seeratul Mahdi on the Aligarh situation of 1889
https://www.youtube.com/live/uQVNrF9fJsk?si=4Q7UkjS94stvsPwW
They were there in Aligarh for 7 days and returned to Ludhiana thereafter.
At page no 72 of his book Seeratul Mahdi Vol-1 (Story #99), Mirza Bashir Ahmad writes that Hazrat sb went to Aligarh in 1889. Abdullah Sinauri, Shaikh Hamid Ali and Mir Abbas Ludhianvi were with him. People in Aligarh arranged a lecture of Hazrat sb for which his approval was obtained in advance. An Ishtihar was published giving date, time and venue of the Lecture. When everything was ready and the time of Lecture came near, Hazrat sb refused to deliver the lecture by saying that Allah has stopped him from delivering this lecture. The organisers insisted and said, huzur cancellation of lecture would bring humiliation to us. But Hazrat sb remained firm and said he will not go against the will of God. So he stayed there for about seven days but did not deliver lecture.
Meer Abbas refused to eat the meat of the “Naturis”, MGA said their food is halal.
The scans from Seeratul Mahdi
______________________________________________________________________________________________
1901
Al-Hakam, vol. 5, no. 22, dated 17 June 1901, p. 4
https://x.com/messiahmalfuzat/status/1813576575486693481?s=46&t=HTqZKquoOvKbgoBAF2aQcg
“””Babu Muhammad Afzal Sahib asked about eating the food of the People of the Book, to which the Promised Messiah (as) responded: As far as social interaction is concerned, even the food of Hindus can be eaten. Similarly, there is no harm in eating the food of Christians. However, having said that, one must ensure that the vessel in which they eat is clean and free from any impurity.”””
______________________________________________________________________________________________
1904
Malfuzat, vol.4, page 66, 1960 edition
Malfuzat, vol. 7, page 86, 1984 edition
Al badar volume 3, number 27, page 3-4, July 16 1904
Al Hakam volume 8, number 22, page 12, July 10 1904
Translation
“””In our estimation, that food of the Christians (nasara) is hilaal, that which has no doubt, this is according to the Quran, not haraam. Otherwise (if this was your attitude) this would mean some (foods) are haraam and they wouldn’t be eaten in the house, however, outside food from the hand of Christians (nasara) has been eaten. And the Christians (nasara), its not just them. If one Muslim is of doubtful personality (insane), even his food shouldn’t be eaten. For example, one muslim is insane, and he doesnt realize the differences between hilaal and haraam. In this case, his food and the prepared meals cannot be trusted. This is why, in my house, we don’t allow the eating of english biscuits, instead, in India (hindustan), we get biscuits made by a Hindu company.”””
Transliteration
“”“”Humarray nazdeeq nasira ka whotaam (arabic word for food) hilaal hay, jis may shuba na ho (doubt), aur az-roo-ay Quranay majeed(according to the Quran), wo haraam na ho. Verna uskay yahee manaay houng-gay kay baaz ashia ko haraam jaan ker gar may to na ka-ea, magar bahr nasira ke khaat se kha leeya. Aur nasara per hee kya mun-hasar hay? Agar eik musalman bee mushkook ul haal ho to uska kanaa bee nahay ka sakhtay. Muslun, aikh musalman deevanaa hay, aur usay haraam aur hilaal kee habar nahee hai. To asee soorat may, uskay ta-aam ya tyar kerda chees-o per kya atbar ho sak ta hai? is-leeyah hum gar may valeity biscuit nahee istaml kernay day-tay, balke, hindustan kee, hindu company kay mungway kertay hai””””
______________________________________________________________________________________________
1923
Ref—Seeratul Mahdi, vol. 1, part-2, pages 422–427, 2018 online urdu edition,
Story #447, Mirza Bashir Ahmad, heard this from Mir Muhammad Ismail, page 409–413, all the way to 422+
In the below, you will see scans from Seeratul Mahdi, wherein it is stated that MGA would eat biscuits indiscriminately. In fact, MGA didn’t care if they were made of FAT.
Transliteration
“”Balkay wilaeiti biscuitoh ko bhi jaiz fur ma tay tha,
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
The quote from the Al-Fazl of 1924
Al-Fadl Qadiyan, 22nd February, 1924
“Hadrat Muhammad used to eat cheese made by the Christians even though it was well known that lard (pig fat) was mixed in it.”
Scan work
The full pdf
A19240222
_____________________________________________________________________________________________1936
Al-Fazl 1936 Oct 23, page 4-8
It seems that in 1936, via the Al-Fazl, Dr. Mir Muhammad Ismail wrote an essay wherein he discussed the nature of revelations, he presented many things. The title of his essay is “wahi wal ilham”, which has something to do with the revelations of MGA. He presented a scenario wherein a backwards servant of MGA who was sleeping next to MGA intercepted some drops of a revelation that was meant for MGA. The sub-topic was entitled “Frishta kee avara wahy”.
In his revelation, MGA’s god seems to be calling him a pig and telling him to get up for prayers. The very next page it says, the 1st Khalifa (Noorudin) was told to stop reading a hindu book, “Ram Mohan Rai”. MGA’s god told him to tell Noorudin to stop is a stern way. The angel said all of this in his own words, and even let out a cuss word.
Watch Mufti Mubasher Shah’s stream herein for a good explanation.
Scans
______________________________________________________________________________________________
1923
1222- IN the Name of Allah most gracious most merciful- Mian Khair Uddin Sikhwani once stated to me by writing that Once i stated some of my weaknesses to Hazoor Elih Sallam and said that sometimes my feelings reach to (low) stage that I (believe ) that i got Hypocrisy in my nature . Hazoor replied in loud style “no -no-Nothing Till age of forty their is no reliance on Good & Bad deeds “and said tell me .I stated that I have seen a dream that i Am ridding a pig in my dream .It (pig) is running very fast . At that instance a piglet is attached to my neck from the back .I tried my best to get rid of it but it is intentionally Attched to my neck and then I woke up.In second dream I saw a Unknown guy pointing towards me and other guy as christian . Hazoor Said that Both of the dreams are good. About First dream is that you will get success over a christian , but didnot told me explanation about piglet………………….
Scan
______________________________________________________________________________________________
Response by Ahmadi answers
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s
Seeratul-Mahdi’s 1st edition is missing, it was published on Dec 10th-1923
_______________________________________________________________________________
Tags
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyat #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #trueislam #ahmadianswers #ahmadiyyamuslimcommunity #ahmadiyya_creatives #ahmadiyyatthetrueislam #ahmadiyyatzindabad #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiyyamuslim #ahmadiyyaincanada #ahmadiyyatrueislam
September 6, 2021 at 9:39 am
Nowzubillah.