As we all know, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad denied the miraculous birth of Eisa (as) as described in the Quran. However, he would sometimes lie and claim that the did believe it it. It should be noted that Sir Syed Ahmad Khan was the first Muslim to deny the miraculous birth of Eisa (as) in the history of Islam and MGA and his team simply copied. Nevertheless, in the below, in 1901, in what Ahmadi’s claim was an inspired speech of MGA, MGA claimed that humans can sometimes be born from the sperm of women only. This was via MGA’s famous Khutbah ilhamiya, which Qadiani’s assert was a revealed arabic speech by MGA and totally inspired by MGA’s god. In fact, MGA claimed that his god took a hold of his tongue, and he (MGA) had no control over what was coming out of his mouth. This was found by twitter handle @zafarim786.

As we all know, Maulvi Nooruddin secretly disagreed with Mirza Ghulam Ahmad on the birth of Esa (as). Nevertheless, Noorudin and his team held the belief that Esa (as) had a biological father until 1903, wherein it is reported by Noorudin himself that he was forced to change his position on the order of MGA. However, after MGA died, per Lahori-Ahmadi sources, Noorudin ordered Muhammad Ali to write in his commentary of the Quran that Esa (As) had a biological father. The Qadiani branch went on to call the miraculous birth of Esa (as) as less then a miracle and some sort of rationally explained phenomenon. Obviously, the classic islamic view is that Esa (as) was born miraculously, just like Adam (as). By the will of Allah.  

By 1917, Muhammad Ali (the lahori-ahmadi) totally rejected the miraculous birth of Eisa (as) and accused Eisa (as) of having a biological father. It seems that in the english ROR of Nov. and Dec. of 1923 has a brief english translation of a few pages.
Khutbah ilhamiyyah, page 86, this was found by twitter handle @zafarim786. 

“””Humans sometimes born only from the sperm of woman, although this is rare and this law is not out of nature, but its precedents are found in every nation.”””


Additional references
Izala-e-Auham, Roohani Khazain vol 3 p.254 

“””””It is no wonder that God AlMighty might have given Jesus some technical know how so that by pressing a trigger or by somehow blowing on it, the clay toy took flight like a bird, or if it didn’t fly it might have walked. Because the Messiah, son of Mary had also been working as a carpenter with his father, Joseph, for twenty two years, and it is obvious that carpentry is a skill in which the faculty for inventing different sorts of machines and instruments is sharpened.”””” 
Ruhani Khazain, volume 6, Jang-e-Muqadas, page 280-281

“Do you believe birth of Jesus without father? Birth of Jesus without father doesn’t amaze me, Hazrat Adam was born without father and mother, Now rainy season is near, (you should) must go out and see how many insects get born itself. Therefore it’s a mistake to take it as proof of Jesus’s being God.”

Urdu Transliteration
“Masih ka bin baap paida hona mantay hain ya nahi?”
“Masih ka bin baap paida honay mari nagah ma koi ajoba baat nahi, Hazrat Adam AS maa or baap dono nahi rakhtay tah. Ab Kareeb Barsat Aati Ha, Zuroor Bahir Ja Kar Daikhien K Kitnay Keeray Mokohray Baghair Maa Baap K Paida Ho Jatay Hain. Pas es sa Masih ki khudai ka suboot nakalna sirf ghalti ha.”(Ruhani Khazain volume 6 Jang-e-Muqadas page 280-281)


1893, in Hamamatul Bushra, an Arabic only book, page 90

“””””The ground on which this is based is his [Jesus Christ’s] creation without the agency of a human father, and the detail of this is that a certain section of the Jews, i.e. the Sadducees, were deniers of the Resurrection, so God informed them through some of His prophets that a son from among their community would be born without a father, and this would be a sign of the truth of Resurrection.””””

Philosophy of the Teachings of Islam

“””We observe daily that thousands of insects infect impure and stale foods and are generated in unwashed wounds. Dirty linen secretes hundreds of lice and all sorts of worms are generated inside a person’s stomach. It cannot be said that all these come from outside or can be observed descending from heaven.”””

roohani khazyian 14 -page 300 (ayam alsulah)

“”5th point is their customs, which are similar to Jews, as their tribes don’t make a difference between regular relationship and marriage. Ladies meet their fiance quite often. Hazrat Mariam used to meet with her fiance Yousaf (Yusuf)(Joseph) before marriage, this is quote sufficient evidence of jewish customs. But these customs are too much between women of tribes of Sarhad, some of these women even get pregnant before nikah (marriage), and its not considered bad, people used to get-away with it and laugh, because like jews they believe “this-arrangement” to be like a nikah, because before it they fix a dowry for it…”


Al-Hakam, June 24, 1901

“Our faith and belief is this that Jesus was born of no father, and Allāh has the power to do all things. The rationalists, called Naturies among us, who try to establish that he was born of a human father they are making a serious blunder. The Lord God of such people is a dead Lord God. The prayers and supplications of such people are not granted who assume that Allāh cannot cause a child to be born independently of the agency of a human male in the role of a father. We consider a man who holds this view to have fallen out of the pale of Islam.”

Khutbah ilhamiyyah, page 86

“””Humans sometimes born only from the sperm of woman, although this is rare and this law is not out of nature, but its precedents are found in every nation.”””



ROR, February–1902
On page 72:

“””On the other hand, learned physicians of the Greek and Indian schools have given instances of such cases, rare though they be, and shown the possibility of a child being formed in the mother’s womb without the seed of a man””””

“One of the doctrines we hold is that Jesus Christ and John the Baptist were both born miraculously . . . And the secret in creating Jesus and John in this manner was the manifestation of a great sign . . . And the first thing He [God] did to bring this about was the creation of Jesus without a father through the manifestation of Divine power only.” (Mawahib al-Rahman, pp. 70-72).


“And this is also a part of our belief that the birth of Jesus took place against the normal laws”…….

“Either we believe that Jesus was born on the decree of God, such is the way of Allah, He creates what He pleases, When He decrees a thing He says to it, ‘To be,’ and it is. Or, God forbid, his birth was illegitimate.” (Ruhani Khaza’in, v. 19, Introduction to the book Page 17).

^^^ These are quoted here.  See page 344.


Noorudin contradicts MGA as he writes his biography and writes that it is not mandatory to believe that Esa (as) didn’t have a father.

Zafrullah Khan tells us in his biographical book on Noorudin as follows:

“”The birth of Jesus (as) without a father had been a somewhat controversial question. Maulawi Nur-ud- Din ra had held the view that Jesus had a father. The Promised Messiah (as), in his book Mawahibur Rahman, announced that it was part of his doctrine that Jesus (as)
had been born without a father. On reading this Maulawi Sahib (ra) discarded his view and fell into line with the view propounded by the Promised Messiah (as).  He frankly confessed this change of view in his book Nur-ud-Din.”””(see “hazratmaulvinoorudeen” by Muhammad Zafrullah Khan, 2nd edition, published in 2006, page 100).

Chashma Masihi 28, RK 356)(See also the online english edition of this book, see, page 29

When thousands of insects are born by themselves during the rainy season, and Adam (as) was also born without parents, it is no proof of Jesus’ eminence if he, too, was born in the same manner. In fact, being born without a father deprives a person of certain faculties.
Badr , May 16, 1907, page 3

“On a perusal of the Holy Qur`ān, this is what emerges as the truth, namely, that Jesus was fatherless; and this is a matter on which no question can come to lie. Where Allāh calls this birth as resembling the birth of Adam, it is an indication that in this birth there is an element of an extraordinary process of nature, to which a reference had to be made, for an explanation, by likening it to the example of Adam.” 
Chashma’-e-Ma‘rifat, Ruhani Khaza’in, vol. 23, pages 171-172

“””And this is one of the mysteries of nature (from God) that it has been noticed that if you hit a squirrel with a rock or stick the squirrel appears to be dead and while the injury is fresh if you bury the squirrels head in a pile of cow manure (gobar) the squirrel becomes alive and runs away in just a few minutes. If a fly lands in water and dies, so too does the fly become alive and flies away. And some other animals like bees other terrestrial insects die in severe cold and remain in the dirt and stuck to walls, then, when summer arrives they become alive. Who can understand these mysteries except for God Almighty””””

Via Barahin i Ahmadiyya, Vol. 5, online english edition

“””It is the law of God that He has not made any human being unique in any aspect, and no one can say that he has such and such characteristic that no one else has. Had such been the case, this would form the basis for holding such a person as being worthy of worship. During the time of our Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, some Christians presented the uniqueness of Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him, as being born without a father, upon which Allah Almighty immediately replied through this verse of the Holy Quran:

Surah Al-e-‘Imran, 3:60

Meaning: ‘The case of ‘Isa [with Allah] is like the case of Adam. God created him from dust and said to him “Be”, and he was.’ In the same way was ‘Isa born of Maryam’s blood and Maryam’s fluid, and when God said ‘Be’, he was. What is so divine and unique in this trivial matter? In the rainy season, thousands of insects are born without a father or mother, and come out of the earth on their own; no one declares them to be God, no one worships them, no one prostrates before them. So if it is not ignorance to create such an uproar over Hadrat ‘Isa, may peace be upon him—without rhyme or reason—then what is it?

Badr, 24th August 1911

“There is another debate, as to whether the Messiah was born without father or not. I say: Did 124,000 prophets have fathers or not? The Shariah has not laid upon us the obligation to make investigation about the mothers, fathers, sisters and brothers of prophets. These matters are not a part of your spiritual progress.” 
Tashhiz al-Azhan, April 1913, pp. 165 – 170

“The reverend says that all Muslims are agreed upon this issue, except Sir Sayyid who has rejected it on rational grounds, but that no one has rejected it on the basis of the Holy Quran. However, I will go on to show that he is wrong in saying that no one has rejected it from the Holy Quran. I will prove that people have shed light on this from the Quran itself and have proved that Jesus was not born without a father, but was born like the rest of the world. What I mean to say is that there have been differences on this issue, and that some people have believed Jesus to have had a father.”

In terms of the split, the two groups never quarreled over this topic at all. The Lahori’s totally believed that Esa (as) had a biological father, whereas the Qadiani-branch remained silent until 1947.
1923, Seeratul mahdi
pdf page 114/316
Narration no. 645
“Dr.Ismail narrated to me that once we were talking about birth of Jesus. Masih Moud (mgaq) said Allah tala created Jesus without a father to show that now bani Israel are not left with a single man whose seed can father (bear) a prophet and now there is end of prophethood in this nation. And time has come for bani Ismail to bear Nabi….”
pdf page 228/316
Narration no. 801

“Molvi M Ibrahim Baqa Puri narrated to me in writing that once I said to mgaq that Allah has parised mother of Eisa (a.s.) and named her SIDDIQA (truthful , pure). Upon this mgaq said here Allah tala has mentioned mother of Eisa (a.s.) to break his ‘godhood’ and use of SIDDIQA is like we say in our language (punjabi phrase) that “o squint-eyed sister in law, I say salam to you” where the objective is to call her squinted-eyed, not to say salam. Similarly in this ayat real objective is to prove that Essa a.s. had a mother which is aginst goodhood not to show TRUTHFULNESS of Maryam “

Links and Related Essay’s

Maulvi Nooruddin secretly disagreed with Mirza Ghulam Ahmad on the birth of Esa (as)

Mirza Ghulam Ahmad and his team went back and forth in terms of if Jesus had a biological father or not

Muhammad Ali (the Lahori-Ahmadi) denies the miraculous birth of Esa (as) in 1917

“Khutbah ilhamia” quotes, the revealed Sermon, April 11th, 1901


#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyat #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #trueislam #ahmadianswers #ahmadiyyamuslimcommunity #ahmadiyya_creatives #ahmadiyyatthetrueislam #ahmadiyyatzindabad #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiyyatrueislam #muslim #islam #qadiani #qadianikafirhai #toilet #muslim  #ahmadiyyamuslims