Intro
On a recent live stream, Bro Imtiaz (via Tiktok live, Timestamp 1:27:14) quoted MGA on the possibility of female prophets from Al-Hakam of April-17-1903 (See also Malfuzat-5, Pages 65-66, Urdu 2022 edition). Firstly, MGA said that the door of prophethood is closed for men, how could it be open for women? MGA added that women are stupid and thus can’t be prophets, he quotes 2:228 (2:229 in the Qadiani Quran) and 4:34 (4:35 in the Qadiani Quran). A few days later, bro Imtiaz showed Part-2 of this very same reference in the Al-Badr of April-15-1903 (page 99-103, not published in Malfuzat)(On 5-21-25, Bro Imtiaz streamed again on this specific reference point (via Tiktok live, Timestamp 1:44:57) wherein MGA says again that prophethood has been negated for men and women. MGA also said that women are servants for men.
In May of 2025, Bro Imtiaz asked Maulvi Raheel Ahmad, Maulvi Razi, Ibrahim Ikhlaf and Maulvi Mansoor Clarke about this exact reference (see 4:28:08 timestamp). Maulvi Razi tried to accuse Bro Imtiaz of not showing the full reference. However, this is not true. Bro Imtiaz was quoting Al-Hakam, dated April-17-1903 (Number 14)(pages 9-10), Razi tried to mix up this reference with the one underneath it, which is from the Al-Badr newspaper (jild-2, Number 15, page 113), of May-1-1903 (dated by Ahmadi’s as April-16-1903), which was almost 2 weeks after the statement about female prophets. There is another reference just above both of these which is in the Al-Badr of April-15-1903 (page 99-103, not published in Malfuzat). That story actually connects with the story after the female prophet story. Thus, we have 2 stories mixed up together and purposely by the Ahmadi murrabi’s. On page 102, it says, that this is the rest of the explanation that MGA gave for the previous question on April 15-1903 (which appeared in the Al-Hakam, dated April-17-1903 (Number 14)(pages 9-10).
On 5-17-2025 (via TikTok live, 2:05:55 time stamp), Bro Imtiaz commented on the reference about the possibility of female prophets. Bro Imtiaz explained how Maulvi Razi was quoting Malfuzat for allegedly April-16th, 1903 (however, this was published on May-1903) whereas Bro Imtiaz was quoting an incident on April-17-1903, which is connected to Al-Badr of April-15-1903 (page 99-103, not published in Malfuzat).
On 5-21-25, Bro Imtiaz streamed again on this specific reference point (via Tiktok live, Timestamp 1:44:57).
In 1999, Mirza Tahir Ahmad gave an answer to a question about why only men were made prophets. Mirza Tahir Ahmad said that prophethood is a huge burden that women can’t bear.
2022 edition of Malfuzat, no sub ref given
