Intro
The Ahmadi mullah team is vicious.  They will do whatever it takes in terms of job security. They are ready to edit the books of MGA and they even published many with MGA’s name on it.
Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya vol. 5 is another case of MGA’s ghost writers in action.

When was Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya vol. 5 published?
It was published Posthumously on October 15, 1908 (See Muhammad Ali, “Prophethood in Islam [1915], the supplement, see for the years of 1908).  However, Qadiani sources are purposely vague.  In a new book wherein they summarize the books of MGA, they simply give the year of 1908 (see page 395), and they claim that the book was written in 1905. However, that is a lie.  A blatant lie.

MGA’s on the Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya series
In 1900, MGA and his team wrote: 

[RK, v 17, pp. 448-458; Arba`een Number 4]. The article is dated
December 1900. In this he censures his critics and claims that he has Divine support etc. Toward the end of the article is the following:

“””If I have received from you the payment for the price of Baraaheen-e-Ahmadiyya then I invoke the oath of God Almighty upon you, in Whose presence you will be made to appear, that [you should] return all those four parts of Baraaheen-e-Ahmadiyya to my custody and take your money back. Look, I make this open announcement that after this if you demand the price [refund] of Baraaheen-e-Ahmadiyya and, having shown [those parts] to some friend of mine, send [return] all four parts to me, as value payable, and if I, after receiving the four parts, do not pay their price, then [may] the curse of God [be] upon me. … And prior to this I have published three announcements, regarding the price [refund] of Baraaheen, which had the same content that I am prepared to return the price. [These people] should return all the four parts of my book and receive from me the few paltry coins that they are dying for. … [Dated] December 15, 1900 AD [RK, v 17, pp. 457-458; starts at last line of p. 457, above the marginal note; Arba`een Number 4].”””

MGA and his teams final words on the Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya series

In 1907, in Haqiqatul Wahy:

16681489_731433183686412_4419116164666868518_n

 

Transliteration
“””Is maslehat se khuda ne Quraan sharif ko 23 baras tak nazil kia ta k us muddat tak mouda nishanat bhi zahir ho jawen. So main yaqeen rakhta hoon k kitab baraheen e ahmadiya ki takhir par abhi 23 wan baras khatam nahi goga k is ka panchwan hissa mulk main shaiy ho jaiga aur khuda taala ne baraheen ahmadiya mein 23 baras ki taraf ishara bhi kia hai..”””

Rough translation
He means if Allah swt took 23 years to complete the revelation of Quraan then barheen ahmadiya will also be complete and published within 23 years and it part 5 will come in that period as this has been told to him by Allah swt.

 

 

Where do Ahmadis get the 1905 date from then?
Nooruddin and Muhammad Ali must have came across a book that MGA and his team were working on in 1905….they then called it Braheen-e-Ahmadiyya and decided to publish it. Ahmadis have already admitted that this book (BA-vol.5) was altogether a new book, it carried none of the themes of the Braheen-e-Ahmadiya series (See Treasures of Islam, page 395).  The Ahmadi mullah team have been notorious for writing books on behalf of MGA and his sons, in fact, Mahmud Ahmad admitted that he stopped writing essays for his newspaper (Tashishazul Adhan) as early as 1911 (see Truth about the split), however, the editors kept using his name in an attempt to get sales.

Conclusions
MGA’s team was very keen, they were all in on the con-job, the main characters were Mufti Muhammad Sadiq, Nooruddin, Maulvi Abdul Karim, Muhammad Ali and a few others.