Intro
In 1897, in Zamima Anjam-e-Athim (1 of 5 books inside of Anjam-e-Athim), MGA and his team of writers wrote that (listen to Bro Imtiaz and Adnan explaining it herein at the 29:00 mark) the Mahdi would be called a Kafir by Muslims (see the full quote in the below) and they would try to kill him. MGA and his team also said this in “Siraj-e-Munir” (see online English edition, page 18).
The same argument was repeated by MGA and his team in 1900-02, via Tohfa Golarrviyya (see the full quote in the below)(See also Araba’in, online English edition, page 91). However, this is a total lie, there are no hadith that exist which support these notions. In fact, in Sahih Bukhari (and many other places) it is explained how Muslims will give salam to the Messiah and ask him to lead the prayers.
It seems that MGA was quoting scholars and calling their assertions as “saheeh hadith”, which is totally deviant. Nevertheless, MGA was quoting “Hujjujul Karama” by Nawab Muhammad Siddiq Hassan Khan and “Dirasat al-Labib” [by Shaykh Muhammad Muin ibn Muhammad Amin al-Sindi] and Futûhât al-Makkiya.
It is also interesting to note that MGA was trying to explain to the world as to why he had been called a Kafir by the majority of the ulema in British-India and since 1884 and again in 1891, when he finally claimed to be the Messiah.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
1897
“Siraj-e-Munir” (see online English edition, page 18
“””Prophet’s ahadith regarding the Mahdi of the Latter Days that he would initially be deemed irreligious and a kafir [disbeliever]. The people would harbour great malice towards him, hold him in contempt, and call him by the names dajjal [deceiver], faithless, and kadhdhab [great liar]; all these [people] would be maulawis, and at that day, there would be none on earth worse in this Ummah than these maulawis. This would persist for a while. Then God would support him with celestial Signs, and a voice would call out from heaven declaring him to be Khalifatullah, al-Mahdi [the Vicegerent of Allah, the Guided One].””””
______________________________________________________________________________________________
1898
Anjam-e-Atham, Ruhani Khazain, vol. 11, pp. 322
Transliteration
“””…magar zaroor tha, kay vo mujhay (MGA) ko kafir kathay, mayra naam dajjal rakh-day, ahadith say saheeha may pehla say farmaya gaya tha, kay iss mahdi ko kafir tarraya jaia ga, iskay vaccat may shareer Maulvi issko kafir kahengay aur asa josht dekhlie-angay kay agar mumkin hota issko katal kar dal tay…”
Translation
“”however, it was mandatory, that they would call me (MGA) Kafir, they would name me Dajjal, in super authentic hadith (multiple hadith), it was already told, that they would call this Mahdi as a Kafir, in his time, the lawful Maulvi’s would call him (MGA) Kafir and cause such an uproar that if it was possible, they would have him killed…”
Scan
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
1900
Araba’in, online English edition, page 91
MGA alleges that those prophecies written in the Holy Quran and the ahadith be fulfilled which
stated that when the Promised Messiah would appear, he would suffer torment at the hands of the Islamic scholars, and they would declare him to be a kafir [disbeliever] and they would issue fatwas to have him killed, and they would dreadfully insult him.
______________________________________________________________________________________________
1900-1902
Tohfah Golarviah, Ruhani Khaza’in, vol. 17, page 213
Urdu transliteration
“””hadith-o-may, saf thor per bat layagaya, kay maseeh e maood kee bee takfir ho-gee, aur ulema a waqt issko kafir tar-eye-angay, aur kayn-gay, yeh kassa maseeh hai, isnay to humara deen kee bakhuny kar dee.”””
English translation
“”it has appeared in many hadith, it was told clearly, that the Promised Messiah would be Takfeered, and the ulema of the time would consider him a Kafir (the Promised Messiah), and they will say, what kind of Messiah is this, he has demolished our religion””.
Scan
____________________________________________________________________________________________
Microsoft Word – Ibn al-Arabi 2 (alislam.org)
(Tohfa Golarrviyya [A Gift for Golarvi]. Ziyaul Islam, 1902. R. K. xvii. 127f, 157, 158, 329).
“”The Shaykh Muhiyudeen ibn-‘Arabi writes an indication of the Mahdi the Seal of Saints in the Fusûs that his family will be from the Chinese areas and his birth will be a rarity for a twin girl will be born with him. So that God will separate the element of femininity from him. So the birth of this humble one was in accord with this very vision and my ancestors came into the Punjab from the Chinese environs in exact accord with this vision.
Remember that these suspicions about why all those Traditions of the Six Authentic that have been written regarding the Mahdi and Promised Messiah thought inapplicable in this place are eradicated with the question as to why it is written in the journals and reports as in the letters of the Mujaddid [Reformer] Sirhindi and the Futûhât al-Makkiya and Hujjujul Karama that the clergy of the time of the Mahdi and Messiah will severely oppose him and call him a deviant and a blasphemer and a disbeliever and the Antichrist and will say that he has ruined the religion and abandoned the
Traditions so he should be put to death because this clearly indicates that the coming Messiah and Mahdi will certainly abandon some Traditions which are considered Authentic by the scholars albeit he will abandon most of them which is why this havoc akin to doomsday will erupt and he will be declared a disbeliever. So these Traditions clearly reveal that the Mahdi and Messiah will appear contrary to the expectations of these clerics of the time and will speak and act in complete opposition to the track of Traditions which they have laid. 9
Which is why he will be called a disbeliever. *
It is such a clear prophecy that unless a person deliberately chooses to be dishonest he cannot question it and it is not the Quran alone that labels such people Jews but the Hadith also confers the same appellation on them and clearly states that the divines of this Ummah shall denounce the Promised Messiah as a disbeliever as did the Jews and the clerics of the time will be the bitterest enemies of the Promised Messiah for on account of him their prestige will decline and people will cease to have recourse to them. These Traditions are very widely known in Islam and even the Futûhât al-Makki states that on his advent the Promised Messiah will be hailed with excommunication from Islam and one divine will exclaim at the top of his voice ‘What kind of Promised Messiah is this who distorts our faith.’ That he does not believe in our traditional doctrines and is antagonistic to our conventional beliefs. Some Traditions go so far as to say that some divines would follow strictly in the footsteps of the Jews so much so that if a Jewish divine had committed incest with his mother so shall they and if a Jewish jurist had entered the hole of a lizard so shall they. It would also be worthwhile to remember that in all references to the degradation of the Jews in the Gospels and in The Holy Quran it is not the public and common people who are mentioned but their rabbis the jurists and the priests and chiefs that are referred to who issue the edicts of excommunication and whose sermons inflame the masses.””
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s
Microsoft Word – Ibn al-Arabi 2 (alislam.org)
TUHFA-E-GOLARHVIYYAH by Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (1902) – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Anjam-e-Athim (1897) quotes – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Tahrif – Sahih al-Bukhari and account of Jesus’ (a) return (al-islam.org)
What is “Hujaj-ul-Kiramah” by Nawab Siddiq Hassan Khan of Bhopal? – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
The Fatwa-e-Kufr vs. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad-1891 – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #ahmadianswers #mirzaghulamahmad #qadiani #qadianism
2 Pingback