Intro
On 12-26-25, the True Islam UK team streamed on the topic of the substitution theory in Islam.
Mansoor Clarke called it crazy. Maulvi Raheel said that ALL Islamic scholars who agreed with the substitution theory in Islam committed blasphemy. This includes Al-Tabari, Ibn Hazm, Zamakhshari, Shah Wali Ullah, Ibn Abbas and Suhaib Webb. Even St John of Damascus and his tract ‘Heresy of Ishmaelites’ confirms the substitution theory (749).
However, the Ahmadi Maulvi’s didn’t issue a fatwa against those who believe in the substitution theory in Islam.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
–At 8:10, Mansoor Clarke begins talking about the substitution theory in Islam.
–At 10:15, Maulvi Raheel begins on the substitution theory.
–At 14:09, Maulvi Raheel argues that the idea of the substitution theory contradicts other verses of the Quran, specifically, 6:164 (6:165 in the Kadiani Koran).
–At 14:50, Mauvi Raheel quotes MGA about some allegations on Eisa (As). MGA allegedly said that one of the allegations was an illegitimate birth.
–At 15:00, the stream goes blank.
–At 19:34, the stream returns.
–At 21:30, Maulvi Raheel mentions a video which they showed at the beginning of the stream wherein Mufti Menk supported the “Substitution Theory”.
–At 26:30, Maulvi Raheel alleges that Salaboo means to put on the cross with the purpose to kill.
–At 31:20, Maulvi Razi alleges that Muslims believe that a Buruz of Jesus (as), got his face.
–At 35:07, audio is lost.
–At 38:45, Maulvi Razi says that if the substitution theory is true, than the Jews who thought they killed Eisa (as) will all go to paradise.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s
Ibn Abbas is the main source for the substitution theory – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Imam Tabari and the substitution theory – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Zamakhshari on 4:159, the substitution theory, 3:55 and 33:40 – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Zamakhshari on 4:159, the substitution theory, 3:55 and 33:40
St John of Damascus and his tract ‘Heresy of Ishmaelites’ confirms the substitution theory (749)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #mirzaghulamahmad
Leave a Reply