Intro
In Dec-2025, Ahmadiyya employees, Humayon Jahangeerkhan, with Mansoor Clarke and Rabeeb Mirza (works at MTA, translation center) discussed the Ahmadiyya concept of Hell.
Interestingly, the panelists said that only Allah can decide who is and who isn’t a Muslim. This is a total contradiction with their 2nd Khalifa, Mirza Basheer ud Din Mahmud Ahmad, who wrote in 1921, that anyone who hasn’t accepted MGA, whether they have heard his claims or not was NOT a Muslim (See page 56). In this quote, the 2nd Qadiani-Ahmadi Khalifa, Mirza Basheer ud Din Mahmud Ahmad accepted that the allegations of the Lahori-Ahmadi’s were true, however, the dates were wrong. On page 61, the 2nd Qadiani-Ahmadi Khalifa gave an example of the eskimoes, who are non-Muslim, however, they have never even heard of Muhammad (Saw).
They didn’t mention the physical punishment that Mirza Masroor Ahmad gave either. In 2025 (Jan), during a Friday sermon, Mirza Masroor Ahmad (19:31 time stamp) told Ahmadi’s to stop stealing land from each other and committing other financial crimes (like land grabbing) against each other. Mirza Masroor Ahmad was so mad that he alleged that Muhammad (saw) once thus described a big sin: If a person usurps even a hand span of land from his brother, the entire land underneath even a small pebble of the land usurped will be placed as a millstone around his neck on the Day of Judgement (See Sahih al-Bukhari 2453 and Sahih Muslim 1612a). It is indeed a grave cause for concern when owing to egotistical and personal interest people usurp others in court cases. This is something we need to reflect on.
Maulvi Mansoor Clarke also alleged that everyone will be gender neutral in the afterlife. At 32:46 and 36:05, Rabeeb says that heaven is a place wherein humans can be 1 with God (naozobillah)(See the clip on TikTok and Twitter).
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
https://youtu.be/x06OIPzxPGg?si=uFNZtTauyboK7lu1
–At 2:19, they start discussing the Barzakh.
–At 3:58, Rabeeb Mirza mentions MGA’s book, “Philosophy of the Teachings of Islam”.
–At 17:36, do ALL Christians go to Hell? Humayon Jahangeerkhan reads off of a script which asks if the person had received the message of Islam first. IF this happened, and a Christian rejected Islam, then, YES! If a Christian refuses to look into it, then the answer is also YES. They go to Hell! If they refuse to read, will they be judged on their deeds alone?
–At 18:10, Maulvi Mansoor Clarke says that humans shouldn’t call anyone a Kafir, this is an injustice. Clarke says that only Allah can decide.
–At 19:35, Clarke says that Hell is a state, it’s a state wherein you displease your creator, all the physical descriptions of Hell in the Bible are wrong (pitchforks and etc). The body of humans is not a real thing, it won’t be set on a physical fire. It’s a body of light!
–At 20:14, Clarke says that Hell is like a hospital. Again, Clarke repeats that only Allah can make a judgement call on who is going to Hell or Heaven. Clarke says that Hell does not have horror and punishment. Hell is like someone who is unwell and going to a hospital.
–At 21:08, Clarke quotes 5:69 of the Quran (5:70 in the Kadiani Koran) and alleges that heaven is for all groups, even Christians, Jews and Sabians can go to heaven (see also 2:62, 2:63 in the Kadiani Koran).
–At 21:32, Clarke argues that Hell is not eternal, it is a temporary state. Clarke quotes the famous hadith about the gates of Hell will be clanking. Clarke argues that some non-Muslims are better than Muslims in their deeds.
–At 23:53, Naseer Ahmad Bajwa starts talking. Bajwa argues that only Allah will decide who goes to heaven and Hell. At 24:43, Bajwa says that there will be some non-Muslims who didn’t receive the message of Islam properly, and they will go to Heaven. Bajwa says only Heaven is permanent. Bajwa argues that Hell being a fire is simply a metaphor. He quotes 32:17 of the Quran (32:18 in the Kadiani Koran) and alleges that heaven is indescribable. Bajwa alleges that there are 2 paradises, one on Earth and one in Jannah. Some people will be reformed in Hell.
–At 30:35, Rabeeb Mirza quotes Muhammad (Saw) and alleges that all the physical descriptions of Heaven are unknown to man.
–At 35:45, Rabeeb Mirza denies the existence of “houri’s” in jannah and calls it a vile concept. Rabeeb says heaven is a place wherein humans can become 1 with God.
–At 37:18, Clarke describes heaven and Hell as a mother.
–At 40:53, Clarke responds to Neil Degrasse Tyson on the afterlife.
–At 46:50, Clarke alleges that martyrdom is kind of a shortcut into heaven. Clarke mocks Muslims and alleges that they are terrorists and etc.
–At 49:44, Clarke calls Muslims who die via suicide and hell bound and gives a hadith of Muhammad (Saw). Clarke says fighting for Islam, gives Muslims nothing! Clarke says to do tabligh instead.
–At 52:26, Rabeeb Mirza says that Mirza Masroor Ahmad told him that being a shaheed doesn’t mean dying on a battlefield. Masroor alleged that this is in the commentary of MGA. Rabeeb alleges that a prostitute one gave a dog some water, and she was later admitted into heaven.
–At 56:05, Rabeeb argues that even some who are regular in the prayers won’t be admitted to heaven. Rabeeb gives a story wherein a praying Muslim critcisizes a non-praying Muslim and Allah punishes the Muslim who prays because he is arrogant and gets sent to Hell. Rabeeb alleges that the good deeds were transferred. The host says that not all religious people are good people.
–At 1:02:40, Clarke argues that souls have NO GENDER. Thus, the afterlife will be genderless. Souls have NO Gender.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s
#Ahmadis don’t believe that hell is forever for non-Muslims – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad and the Barzakh – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad and 2:62, the “Salvation” or “status” of Non-Muslim’s in an islamic state?
Who is Maulvi Mansoor Ahmad Clarke? – ahmadiyyafactcheckblog
Hadith on Suicide: Man kills himself and loses Paradise
Hadith on Animals: Allah forgives prostitute for kindness to dog
Hadith on Animals: Allah forgives prostitute for kindness to dog
In the early 2000’s, Mirza Tahir Ahmad claimed that all spirits in heaven will be gender neutral
https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZP8yms89v/
https://x.com/Ahmadiyyafacts/status/2004639834904953011
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #messiahhascome #ahmadiyyat #trueislam #mirzaghulamahmad
4 Pingback