Intro
Watch my tik tok on this herein. In 1940, in Mujadid-e-Azim, Dr. Basharat Ahmad seems to have invented the story that Dr. Sutherland (See pages 1207—1212) showed up and found Mirza Ghulam Ahmad without a pulse on the night that MGA died, then, a few hours later, via Shaikh Rahmatullah, a leading businessman of Lahore and devoted follower of the Promised Messiah, Dr. Sutherland issued a death certificate which claimed that MGA died of diarrhea, just for the train station to allow MGA’s body to be transported to Batala. It should be noted that Dr. Sutherland himself was not a witness to MGA’s death, nor was autopsy technology available in 1908.
However, this was never mentioned in any Ahmadiyya source until the Lahori-Ahmadi’s mentioned it in 1940. Furthermore, Dr. Basharat Ahmad wasn’t there when MGA died. Nor did he quote any witnesses, thus, his entire testimony is dubious. Moreover, Dr. Basharat Ahmad claims that Dr. Sutherland came to the house where MGA was on Brandereth Road and MGA was already dead. In fact, Dr. Basharat Ahmad claims that Dr. Sutherland said that he can’t help MGA, since he can’t bring a dead person back to life. It should also be noted that Dr. Sutherland didn’t know that MGA had defecated. It was thus a combination of diarrhea and defecation, which is a clear indication of cholera.
By 2020, an official Ahmadiyya publication, the Review of Religions publishes an essay about the death of MGA and mentioned Dr. Sutherland. Furthermore, the Ahmadiyya jamaat has published a new edition of Hyat-e-Nasir recently and have added a footnote and changed the wording.
They claim that a Dr. Cunningham wrote the certificate. This is also new. They also wrote a new footnote. They also won’t give the year of the newest edition. Nor did they translate this properly, in fact, they mistranslated diarrhea and made it dysentery.
https://vm.tiktok.com/ZMeMjaU7D/
Note: Dr. Basharat Ahmad seems to copy and paste portions of the death story from the Al-Badr of
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Who is Dr. Sutherland?
We have found a reference to Dr. Sutherland in “The Indian Medical Gazette, Volume 43″ (From May-1908). He seems to have been an Australian physician of Scottish descent and was an Army officer (in the british army) with the rank of Major and was working at the Medical College Lahore (which is now called the King Edwards Medical College) as the Principal and lecturer. Which is literally 2 miles away from the house wherein MGA died on May 26th, 1908.
Sutherland was the author of Differential Diagnosis of Fevers (1909). He married Princess Bamba, daughter of the Maharajah Duleep Singh; they had no children. He retired with the rank of lieutenant-colonel in 1926 and died at Dunbar.
______________________________________________________________________________________________
Scans and data from Mujadid e Azim, Vol-2, 1940
See pages 1195 to 1212
“””””””””Mirza ghulam exhausted because of writing Paigham e Suleh, and strenuous work of day and night took its toll, “but 25th May the attack (ishaal) was severe which was the cause of his death. at the eve of 25th, writing Pagham e Suleh all day, he went for an “outing” (on a horse drawn carriage), upon his return, he was struck with this disease again. It started to effect digestion (as he went out must have had some food from outside). They send a message to Dr Syed Muhammad Hussain Shah, and he got an appropriate medicine made and sent. But there was no benefit of it. At 11 pm, at night, due to one very loose (dast) motion, Mirza Ghulam felt extremely weak. They requested Dr Syed Muhammad Hussain Shah and Moulvi Noor Uddin to come. Medicine to give him some strength was given. These two people, thinking this round of diarrhoea is due to strenuous brain work, and if he could get some sleep, he will get better. Thinking that Dr Muhammad Husain Shah and Moulvi Noor Uddin left. But around 2 to 3 am same night (please do not forget he already had one attack at 11 pm) he was inflicted by a big ‘dast’ due to that his PULSE COULD NOT BE FELT (NABAZ BILKUL BUND HO GAI). Again Dr Muhammad Hussain shah, Moulvi Noor uddin and Khawaja Kamal uddin were called for. Also Called for Dr Mirza Yaqoub Baig, on his arrival, Hazrat Aqdas (mirza ghulam) asked him to come near, and said “i have severe attack of Ishaal (diarrhoea) recommend a medicine for me, and he (mirza ghulam) said “truth is that medicine is in the heavens (skies) give me medicine and pray for me too.”
Treatment started, as he was very weak, all the people stayed there, and treatment carried on, but the pulse did not come back (LAIKIN NABAZ PHIR WAPIS NAA AAEE). After this Principal of Medical College Lahore, Dr Sutherland, who was a famous Doctor, was called. But there is not a treatment of death. Hafiz Fazal Ahmad sitting near reciting Surah Yasin. At last 26 May 1908, on tuesday at quarter past 10 in the morning. at Ahmadiyya Buildings Lahore Hazrat Aqdas (mirza ghulam) left this mortal world to meet his maker.”””””””””
_________________
Mujadid e Azam Vol 2, written by Dr Basharat Ahmad, published December 1940, states on page No 1205 under the heading “Shaam kee Sair (outing)”
Page 1195 tells us that The wife of Mirza Ghulam was not feeling well and showed her desire to go to Lahore for the change of environment (tabdeely e Aab o hawa), on that request of his wife mirza ghulam performed Istikhara, and he started his journey on 27 April 1908. In Lahore he stayed in Ahmadiyya Buildings, at the house of Khawaja Kamal uddin. As he intended to stay in Lahore for a while, so Moulvi Noor uddin and Moulvi Muhammad Ahsan Amrohi and some other companions (names not given) also arrived. Akhbar Albadr also transferred to Lahore, temporarily so the fresh news could be delivered to the followers. After some days stay, wife of Mirza Ghulam went to see Dr Syed Muhammad Hussain, on one hand she liked his house better and on the other Dr S M Shah insisted for them to move in to their house, as per good medical support so they moved with Dr S M Hussain.
Among other things and meetings going, on 15 May Fazal Hussain visited and Professor Wregge also met Mirza Ghulam during this stay
Page 1205 in Red box, The details are of the stay of Mirza ghulam and his wife in Lahore, 25 May 1908 a day before Mirza Ghulam died, “it was summer time, Hazrat Aqdas (mirza ghulam) accompanying his wife, in the evening, OFTEN went for sair (outing) in Phaeton (enclosed carriage) photo attached. On 25th May 1908 he went out in this phaeton, but he had sad impression on his face, someone enquired, why we see the sadness on Hazoor face. He replied, my state of mind is such like ” a mother as if she had a young child who cannot take care of himself and she were to the child behind”, This was a clear indication towards his death, spiritual mother, the childt she was leaving behind, was “this Jamaat”.
On the picture of Phaeton taken from Zikr e Habib written by Mufti Muhammad Sadiq, it says, “Is main hazrat sahib wisaal say chand rose (daily) qabal shaam kay qareeb hawa khouri kay leay jaya kertay thay”. Just before his death Mirza ghulam used to go out for fresh air, in this phaeton, before the evening falls. So clearly this was the actual buggy used by Mirza Ghulam a day before his death In Lahore.
Scans
This is the horse carriage that MGA was using for his outings while he lived in Lahore. Mir Nasir Nawab was also in the carriage riding with MGA and enjoying the evening in Lahore. MGA caught cholera and died 4 hours later.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
2008
The Lahori-Ahmadi’s mention Dr. Sutherland via a 100-year death anniversary pamphlet.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
2020
An official Ahmadiyya publication, the Review of Religions publishes an essay about the death of MGA and mentioned Dr. Sutherland. Furthermore, the Ahmadiyya jamaat has published a new edition of Hyat-e-Nasir recently and have added a footnote and changed the wording.
They claim that a Dr. Cunningham wrote the certificate. This is also new. They also wrote a new footnote. They also won’t give the year of the newest edition. Nor did they translate this properly, in fact, they mistranslated diarrhea and made it dysentery.
The footnotes states:
‘This is only what the Promised Messiah (as) thought, whereas in order to take the blessed body of the Promised Messiah (as) on the train, it was upon the verification of his physician, Doctor Sutherland, Principal of the Medical College in Lahore that the responsible authority, Doctor Cunningham, Civil Surgeon Lahore, issued the certificate that his death was a result of dysentery, and thus his body could be taken aboard the train.’
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Links and Related Essay’s
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Edward_Medical_University
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Waters_Sutherland
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2020/04/16/the-death-of-mirza-ghulam-ahmad-from-ahmadi-sources/
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2019/08/09/who-is-mufti-muhammad-sadiq-1872-1957/
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2019/02/06/zikr-e-habib-by-mufti-muhammad-sadiq-1936/
http://exahmadi.blogspot.com/2013/12/death-of-mirza-ghulam-qadiani-according.html
http://www.irshad.org/exposed/death.php
http://exahmadi.blogspot.com/2013/12/death-of-mirza-ghulam-qadiani-according.html
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/09/29/hyat-e-nasir-by-mir-nasir-nawab-the-full-pdf-book/
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2020/04/13/what-is-lecture-ludhiana-by-mirza-ghulam-ahmad-1905/
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2017/01/16/hyat-e-nasir-1927-1st-edition-vs-2nd-edition/
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2016/12/02/mirza-ghulam-ahmad-died-of-an-opium-overdose-1908/
https://ahmadiyyafactcheckblog.com/2018/03/13/dr-shadee-elmasry-explains-the-falsity-of-ahmadiyya-prophethood-and-how-mga-died-on-the-toilet-death-by-diarrhea-cholera/ _____________________________________________________________________________________________
Tags
#ahmadiyya #ahmadiyyatrueislam #ahmadiapartheid #Ahmadiyyat #rabwah #qadian #meetthekhalifa #muslimsforpeace #ahmadiyyafactcheckblog #nolifewithoutkhalifa #AhmadiMosqueattack #AhmadiyyaPersecution #trueislam #cholera #deathbycholera
2 Pingback